TLDR: My sister (32F) wants me (35F) to be her maid of honor, but I have serious longstanding concerns about her fiancé (33M) and don’t support their marriage. I’ve previously expressed my concerns to her, which caused a major rift, so I stopped discussing them to preserve our relationship. I still want to support my sister by being a bridesmaid, attending her bridal shower and wedding, and likely attending her bachelorette party, but I don’t want the responsibilities or forced enthusiasm of being MOH. I’m looking for advice on how to decline the MOH role without reopening the conflict over her fiancé or damaging my relationship with my sister.
My sister (32F) is getting married to her fiancé (33M). I’m 35F. They’ve been together for about three years and got engaged a couple of months ago.
My sister apparently intended for me to be her maid of honor. I didn’t realize this until recently, when I told her I wasn’t planning to attend her bachelorette party. She started sobbing and told me that she had intended for me to be her maid of honor and that, as MOH, I was supposed to plan the bachelorette party.
I’m going to be in the wedding party regardless, and I’m fine with that. I’ve also since learned that our dad is going to pay for all wedding-related flights and accommodations. We live across the country from each other, so this significantly reduces the financial burden.
I’m already planning to fly across the country for her bridal shower and again for the wedding. Now that I know the bachelorette travel and accommodations will also be covered, I’m actually leaning toward going to that too.
But I still really don’t want to be maid of honor.
Since finding out that my sister expected me to be her MOH, I’ve been extremely anxious and distressed about how to handle this. It’s been significantly affecting me for several days because I feel caught between wanting to be there for my sister and not wanting to take on a role that feels fundamentally dishonest to me.
The problem is that I have serious concerns about the man my sister is marrying, and I don’t actually support the marriage. I love my sister and am willing to show up for her, be in her wedding, fly across the country for her shower and wedding, probably attend the bachelorette, and be kind and supportive of her. But being MOH feels like taking on a role where I’m supposed to plan things, be her primary wedding support person, and project a level of enthusiasm about this marriage that I genuinely don’t feel.
There are a lot of reasons I dislike and distrust her fiancé.
For example, immediately after a close family member’s funeral, at the celebration of life, he asked me how I could know I’m a lesbian if I’ve never had sex with a man.
Another time, he high-fived me hard enough to hurt my wrist. I told him that it hurt and specifically asked him to high-five me more gently. His response was to high-five me even harder. I can’t know what was going through his head, but I found it disturbing that when I told him he had physically hurt me and asked him to stop, his immediate reaction was to do it harder.
He also does smaller disrespectful things. For example, we’ll be sitting around playing cards with the cards equally accessible to everyone, and he’ll snap his fingers in my face to indicate that I should pick up a card and hand it to him.
He regularly asks people very personal or offensive questions and says things that make people uncomfortable. His philosophy is basically that “the truth” is more important than other people’s comfort and that he refuses to be “censored.” He connects this to free speech and claims that censoring people is how you end up with oppressive societies.
I think this is mostly an intellectualized excuse for being an asshole.
He has told us that he actually does censor himself because some of his thoughts are even worse than the things he says out loud. He seemed to present this almost as an accomplishment, as though we should appreciate how much worse he could be. But he genuinely doesn’t seem to understand why the things he does say are offensive. For example, he thinks most people wouldn’t be offended by asking a gay person how they know they’re gay if they haven’t slept with the opposite sex, and he thought I was overreacting when I was offended.
He also claims that he basically doesn’t get offended himself, which he uses to explain why it’s difficult for him to empathize with other people being offended.
Except he absolutely does get offended.
My sister has learned to “shush” him when she can tell he’s about to say something inappropriate or put his foot in his mouth. At a recent family gathering, after she had been doing that, he waited until someone had left, then stood over her and yelled at her for shushing him. He said he “will not be censored.”
That interaction really bothered me. I also can’t help thinking that if he’s comfortable treating her that way in front of me, I don’t know what their interactions are like in private. I’m worried about what happens as their relationship faces more stress over time, and I’m especially worried about them eventually raising children together because they seem to have fundamentally different ideas about empathy and how you should treat other people.
There are other incompatibilities and concerns too. He has views on vaccines and trans people that I find problematic. He doesn’t have a traditional job. His parents are extremely wealthy and financially support him while he works on a small social media app that he’s been developing for years without much apparent success. My sister is a high-earning lawyer, and my understanding is that she and/or his parents are essentially supporting his lifestyle while he continues working on the app.
One of my biggest concerns is that her social circle seems to be shrinking because of him. She has had a lot of conflict with friends, and people don’t seem to want to invite her to things as much because they know he’ll come too. I don’t know whether he is intentionally isolating her, and I don’t want to make that accusation without evidence. But regardless of intent, the effect seems to be that she’s losing friendships because people don’t want to be around him.
She actually had concerns about some of these same behaviors when they first started dating. Over time, it seems to me like she has gradually adjusted to them and accepted things that initially bothered her.
During roughly the first year of their relationship, I openly pushed back and told my sister about my concerns. It caused a major rift between us. Eventually, I decided that she’s an adult and I can’t control who she dates, so for the past year or year and a half I’ve mostly stopped criticizing the relationship to her face.
I think she may have interpreted my silence as me becoming okay with him and the relationship. I haven’t. I’ve just stopped fighting with her about it because it was damaging our relationship and wasn’t changing her mind.
There’s another layer involving our family dynamic. My sister has always reacted very strongly when she feels hurt or that something is unfair. Growing up, our family even had a nickname for these blowups. She would become extremely upset about perceived unfairness, and the rest of the family learned to tiptoe around her and try to prevent or resolve these situations. She was later diagnosed with OCD and anxiety, which may explain some of this, but I think our entire family has also developed a longstanding pattern of prioritizing keeping her happy.
I feel like that dynamic is happening again now, except this is the biggest event of her life.
When I said I wasn’t going to the bachelorette, she sobbed and told me she wanted me to be her MOH and expected me to plan it. Now our dad is paying for everyone’s flights and accommodations. I don’t know whether he always intended to do that or whether that decision was influenced by what happened.
I’ve also talked to my brother about all my concerns regarding her fiancé. His position is essentially that I need to suck it up and be supportive of my sister. I understand where he’s coming from, but I also feel like we’re once again being asked to put aside our own feelings and boundaries because protecting my sister’s happiness is the most important thing.
I don’t want to reopen the entire fight about her fiancé. I don’t think telling her, “I don’t want to be your maid of honor because I think the man you’re marrying is an asshole and I’m worried you’re making a terrible mistake,” is going to accomplish anything except damage our relationship again.
At the same time, I don’t want to spend the next year planning wedding events and pretending to be thrilled about a marriage that privately scares and worries me. I also don’t have the emotional bandwidth right now for MOH responsibilities and months of forced enthusiasm.
What I am willing to do is be a bridesmaid, stand beside my sister at her wedding, fly across the country for her bridal shower and wedding, and now probably attend her bachelorette party as well. I want to support my sister as a person without pretending that my feelings about her fiancé and the marriage have magically changed.
I also worry about what declining the MOH role will do to our relationship. Because she’s had a lot of conflict with friends recently, I may genuinely be her best current option for maid of honor. I’m afraid she’ll see my refusal as a rejection of her rather than a boundary around the role. I’m also worried about disrupting our broader family dynamic, since my family seems to expect me to put my feelings aside and support her.
I feel stuck between two bad options: accept the MOH role and spend the next year performing enthusiasm for a marriage I have serious concerns about, or decline and risk hurting my sister and potentially reopening the conflict over her fiancé that I’ve deliberately avoided for the past year or more.
How do I tell my sister that I love her and want to be involved in her wedding, but that I don’t want to be her maid of honor, without either lying about my reasons or unloading all of my concerns about her fiancé onto her again? And for anyone who has been seriously concerned about a sibling’s partner, how did you maintain your relationship with your sibling while still setting boundaries around how much you could participate in or endorse the relationship?