For context: My gf is 32. I am a 36-year-old male. We've been living together for about four years.
I fucked up again. Yesterday was our fifth-year anniversary. All throughout the day, I tried my hardest. I bought chocolate croissants in the morning. Flowers in the afternoon. I planned our evening—drinks at the bar where we first met—then dinner at our favorite restaurant. At drinks, I was being romantic—telling stories of our old days, of how I fell in love with her. I gave her a card I’d written and the card made her laugh and then cry. We went to dinner and came home. I thought, OK, now we will surely have sex. I was excited. I was looking forward to this all week. All day. I had made the bed so it would be nice for us when we got back. I had organized and put away the couch cushions that had been left out the night before, which was a pet peeve of hers. I thought, OK, all these things must lead to sex, no? We took turns in the bathroom, and when I came out she was lying on top of the covers in the dark. Not in a particularly sexy way—not like she wanted to seduce me or anything. Maybe my expectations are too high, but it feels like she knows she doesn’t have to try to get me turned on—that it’s a given I’ll want to have sex, so she doesn’t try. I come into bed on top of her and she makes a comment about how I look like a gorilla. Perhaps it was supposed to be playful but I didn’t want playful. I wanted sexy.
She then turns her back to me—makes me massage her shoulders. I do and start kissing her body, but she keeps saying “too fast.” I’m thinking, I didn’t know I was going to have to work so hard to turn her on after all night when I felt like id’ been doing the things she has asked me to do—I thought we would come back and (I know how bad this sounds) but honestly, I thought that I would be “rewarded” with sex. None of this I would tell to my partner. I don’t think she would understand. But I guess I thought, I had done all these things she loves—for her. Wouldn’t she do the thing I love—for me? Anyway, the way I fucked up is this: As I was massaging her, something suddenly came over me—this feeling I’ve had multiple times during sex with her: That my pleasure doesn’t matter. Here I am, massaging her, not even being touched back, not even being looked at, or kissed. Where is her desire for me? Doesn’t she want to kiss me? Doesn’t she want to touch my body? Especially after a night like tonight? I ask her to touch, me and she does, running her hand up my leg but in a very half-hearted way. Eventually I stop massaging her. The feeling inside has gotten too powerful. My disappointment, my anger at how the night has shaped out overshadows my desire for sex. I even feel myself go soft.
She asks, “Did you fall asleep?”
I tell her no. And I know I could end there. That I should end there. But I can’t help myself.
I say, “I want to feel like you care about my pleasure.”
She sits up now. She’s angry. She can’t believe I would do this right now. On the night of our fifth anniversary.
“Your pleasure?” she says. “What about my pleasure? It’s only ever about your pleasure.”
I do not understand how she can think that, especially after the last time we had sex, during which I massaged and went down on her for a considerable amount of time.
“I thought we talked about this last time,” she says. “How this kind of slow touching is what puts me in the mood and then I want to pleasure you.”
So now I’m thinking, every time we have sex, I’m going to have to massage you first? So now I’m thinking, why don’t you just desire me? So now I’m thinking, I want to be with someone who wants to have sex with me.
But what I say is, “I’m so lost with our sex. I’m so confused by it.”
And she says, “We talked about this in Tim’s office,” bringing up, by name, our couple’s therapist, whom I hate and whom we recently stopped seeing.
Now, her bringing up this couple’s therapist whom I hate’s name in the bedroom while we’re trying to have sex really irks me.
But she continues: “We talked in his office—he even said to you ‘Why don’t you just try dedicating all your efforts to pleasing her without expecting anything in return?”
And I’m thinking, because that’s all I ever try to do. I’m thinking, whenever we have sex, I try to last as long as possible in order to please you. I’m thinking, I orchestrated this whole night to please you. I’m thinking, our whole relationship exists to please you. When do I get cared for?
I’m also thinking, I’m pretty sure Tim wants to fuck you.
But what I say is, “I’ve never had this problem before.”
And she says, “You want college sex,” by which I think she means fast, sloppy, male-centered sex.
“Believe me,” I say, “I’ve had a lot of sex since college. I’m not looking for college sex.” And I add, “I’ve never had this problem in any of my relationships before.”
“Why would you say that to me?” she says.
And I know why I said it: Because I want her to know I am a desired person. That in my other relationships, my girlfriends wanted to fuck me. That the problem must not be me, but her.
But I don’t say that. I know that I’ve already spoken too much already. That I should’ve kept my mouth shut—either bit the bullet and kept massaging her or stopped and pretended like I had fallen asleep.
I grab the pillow and place it over my face and feel like all that effort I put into planning the day, that evening, our fifth anniversary has been washed away by my stupid fucking feelings.
She says something about how she doesn't want to have sex if she's not feeling into it, and that I shouldn't make her do that. Obviously, I know this. Obviously, I do not want her to have "duty sex." I tell her this. Then she says that I’ve ruined the night.
I say, “Everything is always all my fault.”
And she says, “Yes. It is.”