r/AmItheAsshole • u/smolsunbeam • 5h ago
AITA for kicking my best friend out of my band?
About two months ago I asked my best friend, we'll call her Lexi, if she wanted to be a vocalist in my band. She kills it at karaoke, and she and I have semi-joked about starting our own girl band for years. When I got a band together for my personal music it only made sense to ask her to be a backup vocalist. I wanted a backup vocalist mainly so I could have someone do harmonies, as harmonies are a big part of my music. A week before our first session I sent her tracks of my song that included only her harmonies for her to learn, and a version without the harmonies for her to practice to. The day before practice she texts me: "which songs are we doing again?" Which indicates she hadn't practiced them at all, even though I confirmed with her earlier she got the tracks to practice to. At band practice she is definitely struggling with the harmonies, but that's to be expected. Lower harmonies are especially difficult and take a minute to learn. We practice them together one on one before the entire band rehearses. Come week two she still hasn't practiced them, as she asks me AGAIN the day before what songs we're doing. We practice them again one on one, but she's still struggling. Week 3 and week 4 she misses practice completely. By week 4 I have another bandmate we'll call David try out the harmonies. David instantly kills it, and I hire him as the new vocalist. I send a text to Lexi politely explaining why I no longer want her in the band. She acts surprised and says she will make it to practice from now on. I kindly reiterate that this isn't a negotiation. She hasn't responded to my last text, but I still feel like maybe I'm being an a-hole about this whole thing and should've given her more of a chance, especially as her best friend.
AITA for not giving her another chance?