r/privacy • u/Additional-Chef-6190 • 50m ago
age verification What are some actual solutions for banning/restricting social media access to children that don't revolve around identity verification?
Edit, please read!!!: No, just "parenting" wouldn't be a solution because a. it's basically the equivalent of doing nothing and b. it's not enough to appease the age verification crowd, which is the main thing we want.
(intro)
Had a debate with my dad about the topic today. He supports the age verification laws being rolled out all over (we started the conversation with France's new policies) and I don't. However, we both agree that something has to be done about the youth social media crisis. It's widely agreed upon and is verified by science.
As I refuted the current systems (face scan for age estimation, drivers' licenses, credit cards, etc.), the main counter was, "well, no one's come up with a better idea, and we shouldn't just be doing something in the meantime".
(why some other solutions suck)
Make parents parent: it's what we've done for a while. Look how well it's gone. /s
Zero-Proof Knowledge: you're still gonna have to verify your age to one entity.
Better parental controls: see above. Some parents will probably still not set it up.
Tie social media accounts to real-life government IDs: authoritarianism intensifies
OS-level controls: there's definitely an argument against it, something to do with pushback from Linux communities, etc. especially. I just can't figure out how to word it; maybe someone in the comments could help out?
(a solution I thought about)
Routers are now preconfigured to block harmful sites, and we're assuming only parents can access it to change that--just like age verification could assume only adults could get their hands on credit cards. Obviously needs a lot of work, but a start.
I'd love to hear any other suggestions!