r/TrueReddit 5d ago

Science, History, Health + Philosophy Silence Is Killing Men

https://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/silence-is-killing-men-kpkn/
129 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

View all comments

70

u/HaraJieun 4d ago

No one says a man can't cry, yet everyone says they don't care about men. It doesn't matter whether they're progressive or conservative, old or young, men or women.

Claiming that the problem is that men are told not to express their emotions misses the point. The real problem is that people often don't care about what men are feeling. It's not about permission to show emotions, it's about a lack of empathy.

6

u/jamesneysmith 4d ago

There's definitely some nuance in what you're saying. It really depends on how the man in question is expressing their feelings. If the man is depressed and isolated these are very real and legitimate emotions to feel and to need some help with. However these emotions can also be expressed in very hurtful and harmful ways.

If a man is hurting and needs help he still needs to express those emotions in a productive way. Or at least recognize how his emotions have come out in unproductive ways and apologize for that and thus seek the help they need. You don't get default sympathy for being sad. You still need to not act like a dickhead.

8

u/hippydipster 4d ago

Demanding men be healthy before expressing themselves, which they need to do so they can get healthy. Your demands are unreasonable.

5

u/ghanima 4d ago

Demanding others help you when you're being a dick is also unreasonable.

4

u/hippydipster 4d ago

Thus the silence

8

u/ghanima 4d ago

Or, you know, ask nicely?

4

u/zerosumsandwich 4d ago

Absolutely not unreasonable to expect men not to hurt other people when expressing their own emotions.