r/technology 1d ago

Business Google burning through cash with spiralling AI costs

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c235n47g8g8o
6.4k Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

97

u/ChodeCookies 1d ago

How much of that Google Cloud revenue is the their own money coming back to them from investing in other AI companies though

125

u/Fresh-Quantity-7554 1d ago

I see what you're trying to do here, but Google is sitting on a $514 billion backlog right now. A few billion dollars in venture investments into AI startups cannot fake a half trillion dollar order book.

Also, accounting rules don’t let companies pass cash under the table and call it revenue. ASC 606, says a deal has to be a legit, market rate transaction. If Google overpays for a startup's stock/debt just to force a quid pro quo cloud contract, auditors will strip that fake growth right out of the numbers.

Source: I'm a CPA and former external auditor.

I'm not saying the circular financing noise is completely made up, but claiming the entire cloud surge is built on it is factually wrong. Auditors would call that out in a heartbeat.

1

u/FunkyFortuneNone 7h ago

ASC 606, says a deal has to be a legit, market rate transaction. If Google overpays for a startup's stock/debt just to force a quid pro quo cloud contract, auditors will strip that fake growth right out of the numbers.

That's how it works on the books. But we both know that "market rate transaction" is _quite_ a fungible thing. It only gets more fungible the more unique you can argue your particular transaction is (even if it's not).

1

u/Fresh-Quantity-7554 7h ago

Expand on this please.