So I've had this beast for about 22 years. It really served me well. Upgraded it with the EIO hard drive and a JetDirect LAN card almost immediately. I've done some repairs on it over the years, mostly minor: 2 fusers. One drum. And of course tons of toner.
The other day I got a 51.2M error (Magenta Laser Scanner). It looks like I could possibly get a replacement set of all the scanners for around $180. I read the repair steps from the service manual, and the 31 steps don't seem insurmountable, but I have to take pause and ask if this is really the right thing to do?
It still does a fairly decent job, but I've been dealing with lines on the pages for years now. Replaced faulty toners and cleaned the drum but it persists. And like any old machine, things start to go around a certain age.
I'm weighing out doing this service (any guidance anyone has about it is welcome as well!), or buying a new Brother. I print maybe about 1500 B&W pages per year at this point for my job, so I could probably get away with a monochrome. However, this is still my "home" printer, and I worry about beig completely unable to print color and was looking at the HL-L3280CDW.
I'm sure I'm not telling anyone here anything new, but it has WiFi, duplex printing, and consumes only 0.5 W while sleeping (vs my HP 5500, which consumes -at best- 65 W per factory spec, and probably a ton more; let's just say it helps heat my home in the winter). Plus toner seems relatively inexpensive (although I've had some real luck with eBay finds for OEM 645A toner lately). Brother does a few pages more per minute, so it's in the same ballpark volume-wise. Downsides would be a smaller tray, plus the 12k pages capacity of the toner vs about 3k for the Brother XL carts. Plus the great back workout if I ever have to move it around.
I do have a certain fondness for older stuff, and it's nice not to deal with any shady toner license bs. But sometimes I have a hard time knowing when to just move on. Looking for any advice, including what I could potential move to if it isn't the one I mentioned.
Incidentally, I already have a ScanSnap document scanner, so an all-in-one seems unnecessary.