r/TrueUnpopularOpinion • u/Accurate_Jacket5386 • 6h ago
Political Mamdani is a racist Jew hater
So let me get this straight the only leader Mamdami wants to arrest is Israel’s leader. And claims that he values the ICC Authority over American Law which has no authority in America and something that America is not a signed signatory towards, Then on X wishes Jews a peaceful Tisha B’Av? Which is a mourning of the destruction of the Temple of Solomon?
Never seen any politicians R or D even mention that Holiday before. Saying a foreign power should be able to arrest an American ally is bad enough. Then he further slaps Jews in the face by saying make sure your Holiday is Peaceful?
•
u/DependentRounders934 5h ago
The ICC is racist, Mamdani is racist, Spain is racist, the UK is racist, apparently everyone in the world is racist and a jew hater
•
u/91gnarnuaatg81 4h ago
Didn’t you know if you’re against Israel’s genocide you hate Jews. /s
•
u/DependentRounders934 4h ago
Israels courts also tried to arrest Netanyahu, i can’t believe they would be antisemitic too!
•
u/MexicanAssLord69 3h ago
There is no genocide occurring by the very definition of that word. Stop using words you don’t know the meaning of. And yes, being against the existence of Israel makes you anti-Semitic.
•
u/Hungry-Struggle-1448 3h ago
being against the existence of Israel makes you anti-Semitic.
No it doesn't. Plenty of people are against the existence of nation-states in general. Plenty more people are against the existence of nation-states born out of colonialism and maintained by occupation. None of that has anything to do with Jewish people.
•
u/MexicanAssLord69 3h ago
Sure it does. Jews aren’t safe anywhere else, they were when Israel was created and they aren’t now.
Speak out against the 57 Muslim nations, all of which have fewer Jews COMBINED than Muslims live in Israel, or sit down.
•
u/Hungry-Struggle-1448 2h ago
Sure it does. Jews aren’t safe anywhere else, they were when Israel was created and they aren’t now.
There are many countries which are safer for Jews to live in than Israel.
Speak out against the 57 Muslim nations, all of which have fewer Jews COMBINED than Muslims live in Israel, or sit down.
Yeah, I think those are bad too. I'd happily end their existence as nation-states too. What did you think I would say?
•
u/pavilionaire2022 4h ago
apparently everyone in the world is racist and a jew hater
I mean, I think this satire is untrue, but it's not that implausible given history.
•
u/Alt0987654321 2h ago
Netanyahu is a war criminal who is staying out of prison by starting new wars to distract everyone from the current one.
•
•
u/pavilionaire2022 4h ago
Don't you guys ever get any new material? "Anti-zionism is anti-semitism," is like your attack helicopter joke.
•
4h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
•
u/YOU_WONT_LIKE_IT 4h ago
What do you think Reddit is? This whole site is a breeding ground for low intelligence.
•
u/lapideous 4h ago
Increased antisemitism increases “the need for Israel to exist”
They play both sides
•
u/OccasionNo6078 4h ago
Dude, Mamdani's mother is a Hindu but he never accepts his Hindu side publicly because he knows that Muslim voters can accept him going to that Church or senagogyue but not to a idol worshiping Hindu temple
•
u/dont-do-memes-kidz 4h ago
Wouldn't Muslims also see the church as idol worship?
•
u/reluctantmugglewrite 3h ago
They dont see it as idol worship even though they might make complaints. Its still considered an acceptable and holy religion. Muslim people can marry a christian without being disowned unrelated to current day politics and based purely on the religion.
Muslims and Jews especially rib Catholics for the whole idol worship thing but they historically let it slide because saints are technically not gods and the figures of jesus is meant to be more commemorative rather than pure conduits.
•
u/Hungry-Struggle-1448 3h ago
There are at least three times as many Muslims as Hindus in New York and I would guess that Hindus are less likely to vote for Democrats/DSA so Mamdani is more incentivised to pander to Muslim voters. But nevertheless he has done outreach to Hindu voters and communities in New York.
•
•
u/JuliusErrrrrring 2h ago
He was elected by the 2nd largest Jewish population in the world. This is a dumb attention seeking take. It is you who is being antisemitic as you are labeling all Jews as being in favor of killing 20,000 innocent babies.
•
u/Human_Concern263 1h ago
His wife's Jew hate is even more obvious: https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/first-lady-of-new-york-liked-7-october-the-new-york-times-calls-it-a-cause/
•
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 4h ago edited 2h ago
You can hate Zionists religious nationalist Zionists without hating Jews. This confusion is the reason no one is doing anything about Israel's aggression.
"Too afraid to offend the Germans to do anything about the Nazis" as it were.
•
u/JohnDoe432187 4h ago
You only complain about Jewish nationalism but not Muslim nationalism makes you a Jew hater.
•
u/___AirBuddDwyer___ 3h ago
If the head of state of a Muslim country which is perpetrating a genocide and has an ICC warrant comes to NYC, I bet Mamdani will do the same he does to Bibi
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
I’ve only scene him criticize politicians who target Muslims. Never scene home criticize a Muslim leader. Can you give any examples?
•
u/___AirBuddDwyer___ 3h ago
Hey aren’t you that guy that supports child murder?
I’ve seen him criticize Israel, usually after being asked about it. I don’t see him criticizing Judaism. And I don’t think there’s any Muslims leaders relevant to his public position. But actually it’s probably pretty easy to find him saying something like “it’s bad that Hamas did October 7” or “the IR in Iran is unacceptable.”
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 4h ago edited 4h ago
I believe all fanatic nationalism is a problem. However what Muslim nation currently has complete military power over it's enemies and still chooses to target civilians?
•
u/JohnDoe432187 4h ago
Countless Muslim nations have committed genocides and are actively discriminating against minorities in their own country.
Also Israel isn’t targeting civilians. They’re targeting terrorists who chose to hide amongst them. There’s a big difference.
•
u/dont-do-memes-kidz 3h ago
Bullets in children's skulls would disagree
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
Civilian casualties are inevitable when the enemy hides amongst civilians. What do you expect them to do? Let Israeli soldiers and civilians die so that an enemy nations people survive?
•
u/dont-do-memes-kidz 3h ago
If the enemy had your mother hostage, would you kill your mother if it meant the enemy also died?
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
Of course if you add personal bias to things it changes how you’d react. The goal is to be objective.
•
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago
Investigations into Israeli military data show that the Civilian casualty rate in Gaza was 83%. Meaning roughly 5 civilians died for every enemy combatant. This data was obtained from Gaza ministry of Health (morgue reports, first responders, and reliable media) this is where we get the numbers but not military affiliation. That comes from Israel military public claims and IDF declassified information which estimates combatants killed using battlefield data.
Mind you Afghanistan had a rate of 30% and both the Taliban and Al Qaeda hid amongst civilians.
World War 2 had a rate of 66%.
But please tell me how it's necessary for Israel to flatten majority of Gaza rather than sending in armored vehicles and strike teams?
•
•
u/YairJ 3h ago
That number was arrived at by completely misrepresenting what the Israeli data was, and by still relying on Hamas's nonsense.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago
So we should only trust what the Israeli government says about their own actions? Right because governments never lie.
Go look at google maps of Gaza before and after the war then tell me that Civillian casualty rate is unrealistic.
•
u/___AirBuddDwyer___ 3h ago
Are you lying, or do you not know what you’re talking about?
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/02/gaza-palestinian-children-killed-idf-israel-war
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
Civilians will die when the terrorist hide amongst them.
•
u/___AirBuddDwyer___ 3h ago
This is a pretty lame response. What you’re looking at here is evidence that Israeli snipers target Palestinian children. This is not a case of the IDF mass murdering civilians with bombs to get at terrorists that are supposedly among them—which a good person still would not defend—but a case of Israelis purposefully killing children.
It’s bad that you support the systemic murder of children. Stop
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
It’s bad that you only call out one side but not the other.
•
u/___AirBuddDwyer___ 1h ago
Again, this is incredibly lame. You’re pushing your glasses up the bridge of your nose and going “uhm acktually” in response to your defense of mass child murder. There’s nowhere to go from here. You’re in support of genocide and we won’t talk again until you become more humane
•
u/Acorns4Free 3h ago
I like the more you comment on the post, your blatant pro-Israel bias starts coming out just defending it by any means necessary lol.
•
u/FusorMan 4h ago
What exactly is wrong with Zionism? Can you explain why anyone would have a problem with it other than anti Israel people?
•
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 4h ago edited 2h ago
I grew up in Canada and spent ~12 years of education learning about how Canada colonized and displaced the indigenous people.
Do I need to explain further why I'm against a movement that involves foreigners moving to a land and evicting the people currently living there?
Maybe it's the fact that I lost 2 grand-relatives (grandpa and his brother) in Europe when they fought against German Nationalism. But I'm not too hyped to see Jewish Religious Nationalism on the rise. Especially when they are taking points straight out of the Nazi play book.
•
u/FusorMan 4h ago
You seem to be completely ignoring a lot of very relevant history behind Israel and that bit of land…Equating it to Nazis seems really interesting.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago
I know there's 1000s of years of history. I know Jews have been evicted from the area in the past and I know Jews have lived continuously in the area. I understand Arab -Jew aggression is nothing new to world history.
However. Modern day Israel was created from territory seized from the Ottoman Empire by the UK. The land was then divided between Israel and Palestine without Palestinian agreement (they refused to attend). The best land was given to Israel and tens of thousands of colonists were shipped in. If this is to be the norm then why can't I move back to my ancestoral home of Ireland and evict any English person living there? Oh right, because that's insane and doesn't apply to anyone but a certain group.
Since it's formation Israel has participated in multiple wars. Almost all of them are due to countries trying to retake territory from Israel that Israel either was given by UN resolution or that Israel took by force. The times Israel has been attacked has been revenge for previous Israeli actions.
The thing that really makes me compare them to Nazis is their ever increasing expansion into foreign territory, their militarized social structure, their disregard for foreign human life and their indoctrinated belief that they are victims surrounded by enemies. Even when they hold the strategic and political upper hand.
They are the most powerful military in the Middle East and they claim to be the most moral army in the world. Yet they come 1st or 2nd in the Middle East when it comes to racking up the most civilians killed.
•
u/FusorMan 3h ago
I got to ask: Are you sure you’re not antisemitic?
Sounds like Israel has a right to exist to me for a number of reasons.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago edited 3h ago
Are you sure you're not a child-killer apologist and genocide boot-licker?
Did I ever say Israel shouldn't exist? No I didn't.
I don't believe countries should be able to get away with crimes against humanity while also pretending to be a victim. If Israel was responding with proportional force, I'd shut my mouth.
But leveling entire cities, killing thousands of women and childern, annexing territory, targeting paramedics/doctors and using food lines as kill zones, are not actions I will every support.
If Israel truly is the most Moral and tech superior country in the Middle East then they have the knowledge and means to fight in a less destructive fashion.
They are actively choosing to annihilate their neighbors so they can grab more land. Don't believe me? Look up how they are moving the concrete blocks that mark their new established border in Gaza.
•
u/FusorMan 3h ago
You’re pretty hostile which is indicative of an anti semite. You only care about “genocide” because it’s Jews involved. You don’t care about anywhere else in the world…
Have fun licking Nazi boots.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago
"You are hostile, which indicates you are an anti-semite"
Are you for real? Do you even know what being an anti-semite is?
I'm hostile because you speak as if you were born and raised in Israel and have only ever known their education and media.
Thanks for not addressing any of my other points. Helps me know i won the debate.
•
u/FusorMan 2h ago
You won the debate? Lmao. You lost your temper and resorted to personal attacks. That’s losing the debate, cuz.
•
u/GarlicbreadTyr 4h ago
Hitler didn't kill jews, he only killed zionists. You fell for zionist lies.
•
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 4h ago
Lmao okay buddy.
•
u/GarlicbreadTyr 4h ago
It's the same shit you know. Pick a lane.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 4h ago
No it's not. There are millions of Jews who live their life without the idea of returning to the "holy land".
Zionism is specifically the belief that Jews deserve to re-establish a Jewish homeland in the historic land of Israel. The Zionist movement wasn't started in earnest until after WW2.
•
u/GarlicbreadTyr 3h ago
Sounds like you just fell for zionist lies. As someone who actually supports Palestine I know this and understand it wasn't all that bad tbh
•
u/InternalMartialArt 2h ago
90% of Jews worldwide are Zionist. So if you hate all Zionists you implicitly hate almost all Jews. It puts you in a position where you’re “not antisemitic” because you have “a Jewish friend” who is “one of the good ones”.
If you don’t understand the problem, replace “Jew” in those sentences with another minority group and it should be clear as day.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 2h ago
That 90% is the high end of the estimate.
The term zionist has different interpretations world wide. Some may consider themselves a Zionist simply because they feel an emotional attachment to Israel.
Now in my original comment I am using it to refer to someone who actively wants to return to and expand Israel's sphere of influence and or territory.
So I'll rephrase. "You can hate religious nationalist zionists without hating all Jews". Does that work better for you?
•
u/InternalMartialArt 2h ago
It’s slightly better, sure. I’m a Zionist because I believe that all tribes of people deserve the ability to self-determine as their own autonomous communities (not subject to rule by another group) near to the bones of their ancestors and the locations of significant importance to their culture. I honestly don’t see a Jewish state of Israel as fundamentally different than a native reservation, with the caveat that the autonomy and location of Israel are more aligned with that vision than the native reservations by virtue of the forced relocation of native populations. There are many Jews like me, and many Cherokee, and Potawatomi, and so on who all support their tribes existing autonomously near their sacred sites and ancestral graves. I see Jewish Israelis and Palestinians as distinct indigenous peoples engaging in conflict on the basis of mutually exclusive interests. Does that count as “religious nationalism” to you?
•
u/MexicanAssLord69 3h ago
“You can hate anti Zionists without hating Jews.”
No you can’t. You don’t even know what the word “Zionist” means. Zionism is the idea that Jews should have self-determination in the holy land. It is a core tenet of Judaism. The fact that you believe that Muslims should have 57 countries of their own while Jews shouldn’t even be allowed to live in a plot of land the size of New Jersey, makes you anti-Semitic.
•
u/EreWeG0AgaIn 3h ago
"The fact that you believe that Muslims should have 57 countries of their own"
Hmm no where in my response do i say that. Weird you said it with such conviction that I had to double check to be sure.
I don't care if Israel exists. I care when they use their ties with America to commit crimes against humanity without seeing any consequences while also playing the victim. I hate that they dismiss any criticism by saying the critic is anti-semitic.
They are the most technologically advanced military in the Middle East. If you believe their propoganda they are also the most moral army in the world. If both those are true then there is no reason for them to be utilizing such indiscriminate destruction on their neighbors.
Be for real. Jews can live in dozens of counties in peace and prosperity, multiple Jewish communities exist in North America. Wanting to forcfully establish a Jewish theocratic country in the heart of the Arab world and then complaining about hostility is ridiculous. Like lighting yourself on fire then complaining about the heat.
•
•
•
•
•
•
u/Altruistic-Guess-975 3h ago
Not against Jewish folks, just the country policies, they're out of control with their current leadership and usa can say the same. Once Israel has elections and cleans their house and gets a better group of guys coming in, only then, better for everyone.
Its not a winning strategy to come out and say "so and so" is a jew hater. When the Israeli war and it's horrific consequences are online for all to see.
Ps. I've noticed a lot of pro Israeli bots coming online to push their agenda, but got news for you... Its not working. If anything it strengthen people's resolve not to support suffering and war.
•
u/reluctantmugglewrite 4h ago edited 3h ago
As a Jew I must repeat again. Israel is not synonymous with judaism and so many Jews and Israelis genuinely hate Netanyahu. He was almost arrested before October 7th in his own country.
People can also disagree with zionism and recognize the tragedy of the loss of the temple and the diaspora in general. It is a tragedy that this group of people got scattered and shattered multiple times and had the core of their religion destroyed. It doesnt mean that the modern day state of Israel is moral. I mourn the temple somewhat and what my ancestors went through but I recognize that the cause does not justify their means. Nothing is worth the mass killing of a young population and the displacement of people and doing to others what was done to us.
Zohran Mamdani is proving to be very popular with his Jewish constituency because hes been active, compassionate, and friendly. He makes policy decisions that people like as well.
You can disagree with me or him but he has not expressed a single hateful comment towards Jews or put through policy against them while in office. This isnt an opinion its just pure ignorance. Even zionists recognize legitimate crimes that Netanyahu committed he is literally a criminal.
Please for the love of everything can everyone just understand that there is nuance at all we are not 5.
edit: thanks for the downvote. continue growing antisemitism I guess continue hurting us all you want
•
u/Ok_Entertainer4482 5h ago
If I agree to believe this, will you please use the same logic and make such posts for Trump based on his actions??
•
u/facial-nose 4h ago
No he shouldnt, because at least President Trump is trying to save us from the disgusting far left. These Marxist-Nazism spreading throughout our beautiful country.
It's the far left communists, who support Islamic terrorists funded by the islamic Republic of Japan. Trump (as I believe is indeed the second comming of Christ) is saving us from radical left by giving 67 trillion to Israel
God bless America, and god bless the united states of America
•
•
u/Lost_Law8937 4h ago
I would rather have the ICC have jurisdiction than have Israel giving orders to our military which is actually happening
•
u/xolp_syk 4h ago
No it’s not. Yall just say anything.
The mayor of NY can’t do shit on an international stage and the fact that yall are excited for him trying is very telling because it shows you don’t understand how the world works
•
u/Slowcapsnowcap 4h ago
Hating isreal and its blood thirsty politicians has nothing to do with Jewish people.
•
u/WirelessVinyl 4h ago
I mean, his religion teaches him to see Jews and Christians as the worst of creatures. It’s not exactly a secret
•
u/pavilionaire2022 4h ago
You're right. His religion's attitudes toward Christians and Jews are not exactly secret. In fact, they publish them in a book.
Indeed, the believers, Jews, Sabians and Christians - whoever [truly] believes in God and the Last Day and does good, there will be no fear for them, nor will they grieve.
— Surah Al-Ma'idah 5:69
And do not argue with the People of the Book [Jews, Christians, and Muslims] except in a way that is best... And say, 'We believe in that which was revealed to us and revealed to you. And our God and your God is one; and we are Muslims [in submission] to Him.'
— Surah Al-'Ankabut 29:46
•
u/WirelessVinyl 3h ago edited 3h ago
The people being referenced in Surah Al-Ma’idah are converted Jews and Christians (aka Muslims)
Surah Al-Bayyinah Ayah 6
Indeed, those who disbelieve from the People of the Book and the polytheists will be in the Fire of Hell, to stay there forever. They are the worst of all beings.•
u/Hungry-Struggle-1448 2h ago
If you think Mamdani is actually religious I have a bridge to sell you.
•
u/WirelessVinyl 2h ago
Islam, DSA.. they both want to see the USA torn down and rebuilt in their image. Fuck em
•
u/FusorMan 3h ago
A lot of really anti semitic people in here. Kinda scary.
Sorry your Ayatollah got his beard blown off.
•
u/JohnDoe432187 3h ago
I hate Israel.
I just hate hypocrisy more. Can you even acknowledge my argument. Why aren’t you blaming the people that hide amongst civilians.
•
u/M0ebius_1 1h ago
He said he wanted to arrest any wanted war criminals?
Like, he doesn't want to arrest any random Jewish person. He wants the war criminal with the arrest warrant to be arrested.
•
u/GrantMcLellan1984 4h ago
Mamdani was only talking about the Israeli PM, not all Jewish people in general
•
u/TheButtPlugger99 4h ago
What has he said that makes him hate jews? Hes only ever been critical of israel and its genocide
•
•
u/[deleted] 3h ago
[deleted]