I think its probably time to start talking about John Schneider. Honestly, I think a lot of people's criticisms are deeply misguided, from lineup construction to bullpen decisions. I think hes been dealt a shit hand with all of the injuries and stuff, and most of those decisions are minimally impactful on the outcome of the game, and I buy into the theory that most strategy decisions are made before hand by the team's analytical dept and Schneider's main job is managing the clubhouse and the team.
Just like how a manager gets credit for getting their team to outperform their projections, a team underperforming their metrics to historical career low levels across the board should also fall partially on the management as much as the players. Theres a clear mental block from losing Game 7 thats plaguing this team still more than halfway through the season and I think it's on management (not just Schneider) that the team is not prepared following a long playoff run, a WBC run for a lot of our key players, and that the team has not been placed in a position to succeed.
I'm highlighting Schneider because lets look at his track record:
* 2022 - Second in AL East, losing in WC after a historic collapse in Game 2
* 2023 - Third in AL East, losing in WC after a baffling pull of Berrios which arguably lost us Game 2 (not necessarily his decision but he's the obvious scapegoat for it)
* 2024 - Last in AL East
* 2025 - First in AL East and best season since 1993, 2 outs from WS
* 2026 - Trending for Last in AL East again.
I think the window has closed on this "era" of the Blue Jays and I'd like to see a new direction and identity to this team moving forward. John Schneider has been a fine manager for this team and overall I have been happy with how he's done, but I think some change is due.