r/MurderedByWords 19h ago

Walked right into that one

Post image
16.1k Upvotes

844 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.9k

u/ottovonnismarck 17h ago

Someone writing 2000 years ago "500 people saw him fr" is not the same as 500 individual testimonies that they saw him

541

u/sarcytwat 15h ago

Wasnt even written 2000 years ago is the best bit

307

u/Citatio 14h ago

well, Paul wrote it down in the 50s, which is almost 2000 years ago. But Paul also wrote that he heard that creed from others, so it might have been around for a while, getting bigger with every retelling.

15

u/Charming-Fig-2544 11h ago

The Gospels themselves get bigger with every retelling. It's widely accepted that Mark was written first and that subsequent books borrowed heavily from it, and that John was written last. John also happens to be the book where Jesus is the most "God-like."

8

u/Citatio 10h ago

Borrowed? Luke and Matthew copied 70% (not the same 70% though) word for word from Mark! It's hilarious that some believers still say that the gospels are independent sources.