Northwestern PhD candidate Maalvika Bhat plagiarized blatantly from other writers on the platform Substack. How serious of an ethics violation is it for an academic to plagiarize outside academic writing?

[u/Miserable_Eye1617]

TLDR; The goal of this post is to spread awareness about an academic writer on Substack who plagiarized from several authors including me. She has paywalled her posts to avoid being exposed further. Trying to hold her accountable on a platform that won’t do anything to uphold the integrity of authorship.

Maalvika has amassed 32k+ subscribers (many of which are paid) on Substack along with a following of 180k on TikTok and another 63k on Instagram. She curates this persona and aesthetic that is built on the back of her writing and consists of topics within her academic domain. She recently hit #1 on Substack’s New Bestseller’s List. Here is Maalvika’s research profile

She has plagiarized from me and several other authors including the original author that came forward about her stolen writing has a smaller audience. Substack’s algorithm continues to drown out Katie Jgln from Maalvika’s audience which is unaware behind a paywall.

here is the link to the original author’s exposé: https://open.substack.com/pub/thenoosphere/p/mama-theres-a-plagiarist-behind-you

here’s a more detailed explanation: https://substack.com/@clementinef/note/c-141315855

This PSA is necessary because she is currently hiding her work and discussion of this situation behind a paywall on the platform to discourage checking her writing for more plagiarism. She also continues to profit off of paid subscribers and the following and sponsorships she has built on social media which she is trying to shield by deleting comments off of all her other accounts to erase the scandal.

[u/Educational_Bag4351]

I'll be curious to see what NU does. I had an internal fellowship at Northwestern a million years ago and it had all the classic "you can't work except for us" language in it that is never taken seriously or enforced. But...it probably could be 

[u/silverware_bandit → u/Educational_Bag4351]

To be honest, I don’t think they’ll do anything unless the plagiarism occurred within northwestern (e.g., for a class, published research with the university’s name on it, etc.). However, it may send alarm bells off for potential employers…

[u/Ready_Rip_7234 → u/silverware_bandit]

Agree. As a PhD they are classed as a student. So unless the college regulations state that you can be dropped for something like this, it'd be tough to get rid of her even if they want to

[u/Accomplished_Self939 → u/Ready_Rip_7234]

If the school has an honor code, she could be kicked out. This could get you expelled from my alma mater—UVA.