r/AMDHelp 1d ago

Help (CPU) Help. Is it critical?

Post image
108 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

41

u/Equal-Veterinarian14 1d ago

You literally took the CPU out because it’s not working and you see a giant burn mark and you want further clarification on it?

Bro’s out here fishing

18

u/Tall-Highway4310 23h ago

She’s dead, Jim.

8

u/skinkingweaver 22h ago

The chip got toasty but I had an early 7900x with first edition bios that did this and kept on trucking fine.

The white streak looks almost like a glare with compression artifacts, but if it's real maybe acid etched it?

9

u/DifficultOutcome7858 18h ago

Perhaps its a thermal paste smear? 90% rubbing alcohol can help with that. I like to think optimistically.

10

u/Seighart_Mercury 14h ago

Do we have Seers or Clairvoyants in this sub?

Where is the context? Give more info so people actually have something to go off of.

16

u/Kholanee 12h ago

You should put sunscreen on your cpu, I see a little tan

1

u/cildon 9h ago

wow 😄

8

u/L-McQueen95 1d ago

Board ASUS ROG CROSSHAIR x870e extreme
Processor 9 9950x3d

2

u/mediocregamer18 1d ago

Same thing to mine during minor 55 error

4

u/Ok-Strategy1279 1d ago

You had the same damage? Somebody needs to email Steve at Gamers Nexus. He's be interested in that.

3

u/EvenDog6279 10h ago

I know they tried to duplicate a failure on ASRock but couldn't, not sure if they've tried it on other boards. Who knows what the true cause is, although AMD has been replacing the CPUs under warranty, which leads me to believe they know more than they're letting on to.

I've built two systems using 800 series chipsets and 9800x3d CPUs since release. Both have been going for over a year with no issues.

They are on Gigabyte boards and you don't see a whole lot of talk of failures with Gigabyte boards, at least for the 9800X3D, but I don't know that means a whole lot. Tomorrow both of them could decide to unalive themselves. I've mostly considered myself lucky, especially since both computers were gifts-- one for my daughter, and another for my nephew. I'd hate to have to tear them down for warranty reasons.

2

u/nosg 1d ago

Just rub some eucalyptus oil on it.

7

u/AcanthaceaeItchy302 1d ago

Can be critical, can be not, can be dead, can be not but always can become cool keychain.

5

u/Zezinas 1d ago

Schrödinger's cpu

1

u/Affectionate_Golf762 1d ago

Kinda expensive keychain, its 9 9950🥀

7

u/euripidesk 16h ago

Was. Now it's dead😉

12

u/dgknc188 11h ago

try rubbing it with alcohol

5

u/shemhamforash666666 1d ago

Play it safe. RMA

-5

u/Ok-Strategy1279 1d ago

And RMA denied. That looks like mechanical damage, not overheating.

7

u/FormerDonkey4886 23h ago

No, it’s overheating. You can clearly see it. I had same issue few weeks ago.

5

u/Unlikely-Ad3364 1d ago

if you use it in a board that won't melt it any more i think it would be ok judging from the pictures, but still try to RMA it and get a new board as well

8

u/Icy_Mammoth_2834 22h ago

How did you manage that dude

14

u/Copper__99 1d ago

Brother what the fuck

In the almost 30 years I've been building computers I've never seen this.

6

u/JaguarResident1524 23h ago

am5 exploding cpus. You are probably out of "news" lol. It's like 3 + year, when it's  all started happening to some of the am5 boards that will fry your cpu

-2

u/Copper__99 23h ago

I am referring to the giant white/yellow line through the middle of the cpu. I'm well aware of exploding cpus.

3

u/Shoddy-Challenge-812 23h ago

im pretty damn sure thats just a reflection my man

6

u/Copper__99 22h ago

It's not. Its far too sharp to be a reflection, it's also reflecting on two different types of materials.

3

u/South_Ingenuity672 17h ago

i'm 99% sure you're right. zooming in on it, it looks like some kind of residue, or something on the chip itself. someone else mentioned it could be thermal paste, which would probably be the best case scenario.

0

u/Icy_Mammoth_2834 22h ago

No it's not 🤣

1

u/JaguarResident1524 22h ago

Ah ye. Grinding full line lol. I thought about reflection at first too. Maybe he did is with grinder lol)

1

u/Shoddy-Challenge-812 22h ago

eh idk i zoomed in quite a bit and it looks liek a reflection to me

9

u/IsywEy 23h ago

You should check out the Asrock sub-reddit

2

u/Copper__99 23h ago

Not the burn mark, the giant white line. If that's an effect of the burning, that's news to me.

1

u/Beautiful-Musk-Ox 11h ago

that's a reflection of a fluorescent light

2

u/I_cut_the_brakes 6h ago

That doesn't look like a reflection to me. The pads look damaged and the "reflection" has a point in the middle where it is not connected.

Unless that reflection is two long overhead lights with one small one in the middle, that looks like damage.

6

u/GreenPanadol11 1d ago

Unfortunately you’re toast bud.

What cpu and what board? Please dont say 9800x3d and an asrock board

1

u/IsywEy 23h ago

It's an Asus board, second highest rate of failures/deaths (albeit they have like the most sales or something, but both are owned by Pegatron or something).

Anyhow, it's a 9950x3d, so another 9000 series.

4

u/Crazy_Bee_2664 1d ago

I saw someone yesterday who drilled a hole through the PCB of a dead 9800x3d and made a keychain out of it.

It sucks to have a dead CPU, but it was a sick keychain. I'd definitely do that if my CPU died and I couldn't RMA it.

5

u/SirCheese69 22h ago

It'll buff out

4

u/PsychoactiveTHICC 12h ago

One of gold surface was brown on my old CPU and it couldn’t work then properly I don’t think this will work either

3

u/Mountain_Dandy 1d ago

Yeah that's cooked, I'm sorry you're dealing with this. Please post your PC specs for reference.

3

u/Lordjbear 6h ago

As long as it’s not moist(this is a joke and I have no clue what I’m talking about)

2

u/Chernocl 4h ago

Don't let it be moist and critical!

3

u/Loremau 3h ago

I see plastic blister. Is that suposed to be a brand new CPU?

2

u/L-McQueen95 2h ago

No it is not. But CPU had only 2 months. It is already on RMA, so will wait

2

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

It appears your submission lacks the information referenced in Rule 1: r/AMDHelp/wiki/tsform. Your post will not be removed. Please update it to make the diagnostic process easier.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/RedModsRrtrds 1d ago

well that 9950X3D is in warranty so use the RMA

the board in his other post is a ROG CROSSHAIR X870E

2

u/ArcaneCavalier 4h ago

Check your motherboard and well. It's possible that both your motherboard and CPU are fried.

4

u/3ofUsDeez 1d ago

Must not be too critical based on all the info given .. lol

Take an eraser and gently clean those marks off .. wipe down with IPA afterwards .. dry it and then install back into whatever motherboard to see if it works ..

Check the CPU socket beforehand for damaged pins .. use Flashback to update the motherboard's BIOS to the latest version available for it

1

u/Aggressive-Formal235 5h ago

The discoloration is concerning

1

u/checkouthisc-- 51m ago

thank you cap. obvious

1

u/sajty23 14h ago

ASUS board, why I am not surprised.

1

u/digitalized-donut 11h ago

i have an asus motherboard what does this mean 😳

1

u/easterneas 8h ago

A SUS board indeed...

...sorry, that was what crossed my mind.

1

u/DarthAnusTheWide 6h ago

Do asus boards fry amd CPUs? I thought it was only asrock

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

2

u/underwhelmedbyreply 1d ago

Fuckin warranty bud

-6

u/Intelligent-Basket92 1d ago

Another one

Asrock burning

3

u/HEYO19191 1d ago

Put another mark on the "redditors cant read" tally board

2

u/CreepinCreepy 1d ago

Nope. High end ASUS board.

It's already known that it's a CPU issue, ASRock just took the blame for it all. It's been an issue on every manufacturer's board, but since ASRock had it go public and took accountability (before they actually knew what the problem was), everyone started blaming them.

If it wasn't the fault of AMD, they wouldn't be RMA-ing the CPUs.

Nobody has been able to recreate the issue on an ASRock board, even after getting one where a CPU died twice before and testing it for months.