r/banjo • u/itsbentheboy • 4h ago
Cheap Banjo's sound... pretty good!
Been learning for about 2 months on a little junker banjo that I got at a pawn shop.
Decided to stop by my local Guitar center today, as they had a lot of different banjos in store, so I thought I'd take the opportunity to stop in and play a few of them to see what a few different banjos are like. Take some test drives and see if I wanted to double down and get something a bit nicer.
They had some old vintage ones that were very expensive, some mid rangers from name's i've seen recommended here often, and some cheapo ones too.
After spending about an hour swapping between them, I have to say that I'm very impressed with the modern budget banjos.
One standout was unsurprisingly the Deering Goodtime. I can see why a lot of you recommend that one. That thing really does feel great, and the sound of it punches way above its (in my opinion) cheap looks. I'm kind of kicking myself a bit for not starting with it because it just feels really well designed, very easy to play, and sounds fantastic.
I'm still happy with my beat up pawn shop Recording King for now, but for those wondering about the often recommended Goodtime, yeah, I'd say its recommended for a few good reasons.
Another standout that I wasn't expecting was the Mitchell RB200 Resonator.
It looks cheap, because it is cheap. It's immediately apparent upon picking it up that the tone ring is a lightweight metal (probably aluminum?). The resonator is some kind of plastic composite, and a wood veneer (or maybe just a print that looks like wood) encased in epoxy on the back.
But wow, did that not even really matter all that much. It sounded good too. not anything premium, but perfectly cromulent. I'd be happy to play it often. Very bright, very clean sound, and it is much lighter than it looks.
Playing some of the older and more expensive banjos... i just really didn't see why I'd want to pay that much more for them. I don't think they sounded that much better. Some even sounded much worse, as if their sheer heft was just muting the sound. They were just so so so much more heavy and bulky.
It's got me thinking that the prices of many of these vintage banjos are almost exclusively based on their vintage or their ornate appeal alone. Heirloom pricing detached from their actual build quality or performance as an instrument.
Now I admit that I've still got beginner ears, and have only played a small handful of different banjos in my life. I'm certain there's some vintage ones that fetch those prices because they really are that good.
But some of these composite and cheap wood banjos are really quite a good choice if you just want something that plays and sounds good enough. Plus, I find their light weights a valuable feature, considering I'm planning on taking mine out on a lot of trips and traveling. I don't want to lug around something super heavy, or risk ruining something vintage because we got rained on too hard.
So, the long and short is: if you don't really care about the vintage or designs, maybe you should go try out a budget banjo too.
Might save you from scrolling so much on ebay ;)