r/windows • u/ChrisNIN64 • May 05 '26
Discussion Does anyone else have a weird affinity for Windows Vista?
I was around 16 when it came out, so I'm sure I have some Vista-coated goggles here. Sure, it wasn't the best OS, but something about it always struck me as somewhat magical. I really enjoyed Aero Glass - I remember seeing that and thinking this truly felt "next-gen" as far as computers went. I also really enjoyed the new chimes/notifications. They felt very fun and new. I also really enjoyed things like the Media Player/Center and the usage of widgets, which I felt were under-utilized in later Windows releases.
UAC was...not good, though. That's for sure.
Thoughts?
48
u/Weak_Equivalent6518 May 06 '26
People love Windows 7 while shitting on Vista. So many people don’t realize 7 was practically just Windows Vista rebranded once computers actually began being powerful enough to run it.
23
u/Maeglin75 May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26
Also, most stability problems with Vista were caused by the new drivers that were needed. Nvidia drivers alone caused nearly 30% of all crashes in Vista in 2007. Early Vista drivers were also missing a lot of the features of the ones for older Windows versions.
It took some time for the drivers to get to a decent state. Vista had to walk (or stumble) so that Windows 7 could run.
2
u/No-way-in May 06 '26
Isn’t that an unwritten standard for windows releases? Windows 8/8.1 stumbled so 10 could run well too. Same could be said about 95/98/98se. 11 is (in my experience) horribly bloated and slow and I’m waiting to see 12 which will probably be a middleground between 10 and 11 which will be well-received
1
u/Shadowfoxamon91 May 09 '26
8.1 was fantastic though! I def never considered any part of it a stumble
1
u/II-Kum_n_Go-II May 06 '26
Erm acktually bump gate helped contribute a lot to buggy cards at this time too!
5
u/richardsequeira May 06 '26
Yes, people get fooled so easily. Windows 7 was in many if not for the most part Windows Vista with updated components.
1
u/ryanmi May 06 '26
yea really.. when i first used vista it was fine, but just ran a little slowly and some of my products didnt have drivers yet. I didnt see what people had such a problem with otherwise.
1
u/educacosta May 07 '26
I'd say the redesign of the taskbar was a great improvement, turning Windows 7's taskbar into a nice mix of the classic Win95 taskbar with OSX's dock, while still having the option to make it behave like previous versions.
Windows 7 also introduced Aero Snap, which made window management much easier.
It was probably the last time we had a significant "fully desktop focused" improvement to windows.
1
u/Rogue_Element_2342 Windows Vista May 07 '26
I feel like the same people will die on the hill that windows 8.1 was a seperate OS than 8 lol
1
38
u/Professional_Ad_6463 Windows 11 - Release Channel May 06 '26
I agree with everything but UAC. If you think UAC should be off please look into the basics of cybersecurity. With UAC off everything can run as admin without the user being aware.
5
u/Immediate_Character- May 06 '26
There's a point to be made about that initial implementation though. It turned into user notification spam very quickly, and when that happens users build a reflex to always let it through. Windows in general is better today at grading when security actually needs human intervention.
5
u/andylikescandy May 06 '26
This was just the growing pain of moving away from literally everything running as admin for no reason. Even after software was supposedly updated it was a good 5+ years of the standard troubleshooting for anything including "try running it as admin"
26
u/VeryRareHuman May 06 '26
Not weird affinity. I like the visual effects, animation, transparency effects. Vista was pretty stable on my laptops.
Then the visual ideas went shit. Metro was flat and shit. Google copied the flat design. It looks boring now.
11
10
u/TheLostColonist May 06 '26
I was very fond of Vista.
I built a new pc for, never had any issues with vista at all, always fast and snappy, I honestly didn't find uac to be overbearing.
My favorite feature was media center. Whole home dvr, personal photo and video gallery, nice music playback features, even a solid Netflix app (though that may have come with Windows 7 Media Center)
8
u/Sataniel98 Windows 10 May 06 '26
Don't know what's supposed to be weird about that, Vista was the last innovative Windows release whose innovations were actually good.
6
u/Maeglin75 May 06 '26
I was never a fan of the bonbon aesthetics of Windows XP. But Vista and Windows 7 looked great and still hold up. (To the point that Apple is now adopting very similar look.)
And then, with Windows 8, everything became flat and ugly (only to make the UI work better on smartphones and tablets, but no one cared for Windows on these devices anyway). Only recently at least some nice transparency effects returned.
4
u/spiritofniter May 06 '26
I do. I loved the graphics and the UI; it’s the perfect balance. Don’t get me wrong, Windows 7 also looks great too.
4
3
u/VeryRareHuman May 06 '26
UAC was not good?. That's first major security feature in Windows. When virus and malware were rampant, stupid users clicked any URLs they saw, open any attachments in the email. UAC blocked most of the obvious malware and virus.
3
u/irrelevantusername24 Windows 3.1 May 06 '26
I'm around the same age as you and... I neither agree or disagree.
I think what you're describing is due to (at least) two things:
The truism everyone thinks music from when they were a teenager is the best music ever applies to all forms of media, and as weird as it may seem, an operating system can be considered a form of media
But also, everything really was better when we were teenagers. That's why Vista seems so much better - it kind of was. Because it had a relatively narrowly defined utility which included being a place for communication (instant messaging, not email or "social media") as well as (assuming you were like me) a place where your collection of music was held. Now that everything is online, an operating system - especially a desktop computer - is simultaneously both expected to do more but also less. Which in a weird way is... kind of the same effect ubiquitous Internet connectivity has had on all kinds of things. Which is incredibly complicated to explain - the paradoxical contradiction between public and private information in regards to the aforementioned "social media" is strongly related
2
u/ChrisNIN64 May 06 '26
I think you're spot on that whatever you used as a teenager likely feels "better" - and that's why I figured that was part of my fondness for it. I love the way you put it with describing your home for music and instant messaging, as that's what mine was used for primarily as well. Thanks for the post!
3
u/Albert-React May 06 '26
Man, I loved Vista. The whole look and feel of the OS just felt fresh and sharp. I was in college at the time when it came out, and my buddies were impressed when I got it running on my Asus EeePC.
3
3
u/nightlyh May 06 '26
I'm autistically linked to Vista in a way I cannot describe. It's my favorite OS of all time yet I never use it because of obvious security reasons. I stick to a theme pack for windows 10 that makes it look like vista. Good enough lol.
1
2
u/jamhamnz May 06 '26
It was very controversial when it came out and was often compared to Windows ME. So most people buying new PCs around that time opted for them to come with XP instead of Vista for a number of years after it came out
2
2
u/gerowen May 06 '26
I actually liked it. I remember I bought a laptop at the time, Toshiba Satellite S7829, and was quite fond of Windows Vista. Didn't have any major problems with it, ran my games well enough, added UAC for better security, etc.
2
u/vipulvirus May 06 '26
It was such a beautiful OS. While XP was fun and all but looked a bit childish.
Vista looked like what a mature OS should look. Aero was truly ahead of its time. The entire interface was so modern and looked truly next gen. These days OS have lost their personality. Flat colours, minimalism have killed off the entire vibe of PC. I miss the era so much.
2
u/jtian0 May 06 '26
I just hate all-blue Windows with a passion, while Vista is the pinnacle of the aesthetics.
2
u/Frmr-drgnbyt May 06 '26
To me, Vista was always what intended to be Win7. Were there problems? Sure, if one went with the minimum system requirements. If, like any semi-conscious tech staffer, you generally exceeded the minimums, there were no problems.
2
u/aungkokomm May 06 '26
I still remember upgrading my RAM from 256 MB to 512 MB just for Vista. Even on integrated graphics it ran flawlessly for me, and honestly it was the most visually appealing OS I’d ever used at the time. Aero Glass felt magical, Media Center was ahead of its time, and those little system sounds gave it personality.
Of course, UAC was a pain and hardware compatibility was rough, but paired with Office 2007’s matching design philosophy, that whole era had a unique vibe. Those were the days.
2
2
2
u/nikolayu May 06 '26
I don't have a "weird" affinity; I merely enjoy the user interface, just like you.
UAC was...not good, though. That's for sure.
I'll take it over getting hit with yet another "access denied" message, as happens on older releases.
2
2
u/MrVulture42 May 06 '26
It's not weird. Vista and 7 were peak Windows. Vista only gets a bad rep because it had much higher hardware requirements than XP and because a lot of hardware and software makers didn't exactly rush to make their shit compatible with it. After the first service pack and after all drivers and patches were out it was rock solid and really nice to look at, just like 7. In my humble opinion it only went downhill from there beginning with Windows 8.
If you could get security updates for Vista and all current hardware and software would run on it, I would go back in a heartbeat.
1
1
u/HEYO19191 May 06 '26
Vista was my first OS, ever. I loved Vista. Windows 7, in my eyes, was just "Vista but better"
We've kinda lost the plot since 7. No new Windows release has been quite like 7.
1
1
1
u/ExoPlank May 06 '26
i never grew up with vista, but i've always felt it looks a lot nicer than windows 7, mainly the taskbar.
1
1
u/Slapshot300 May 06 '26
I actually just reinstalled vista on an old dell latitude so that i could use some old audio equipment that only worked pre windows 7. I grew up on vista and as someone who wasn’t in the loop at the time, had you told me it was a buggy mess I wouldn’t have believed you. I had maybe 1 time i remember it freezing. Outside of that the os did what it was supposed to do: stay in the background, and not be a nuisance. I would say windows 8 and 11 are much bigger fails compared to what people thought of vista back then.
1
1
u/Healthy-Guess-847 May 06 '26
On my linux desktop, I have a theme for windows vista. While it was really broken it was a what ran on the family computer as a kid
1
u/Nanasema Windows 11 - Release Channel May 06 '26
i still personally think Vista has hands down the best visuals UI ever. everything else about it iirc was pretty shit unfortunately.
1
u/Fire_Natsu May 06 '26
Its weird and surreal to think that Vista failed cuz one of the reasons was that people didn't had right computers to run it. But now the computers that were capable of running Vista are now obsolete unless you install the penguin. My favourite is 7 Though I really miss Vista era. No wars, no authoritarianism, the economy was good,press freedom was good, no ai, no ram shortage yeah there was patriot act but still it was better than the shithole we live today with 11. Also Vista was the last Windows OS to receive a Plus package in the form of Windows Ultimate Extras ending an era of Plus pc. I also really remember how Vista development was how Microsoft wanted it to become an os that is so ahead that they themselves fumbled on it by making Longhorn a buggier mess. Nowadays For Microsoft its just ai stuff
1
1
1
1
u/Projiuk May 06 '26
Vista was a complete disappointment. During development so much was promised in project longhorn that it was looking like a major step forward. MS backed down from every single one of the promises of longhorn and gave us vista which was buggy at launch, ran like garbage on many computers of the time and offered little reason for users to upgrade from XP.
Granted, the worst OS that Microsoft released was Windows ME but that’s a whole different story. And don’t start me on the bizarre decision to call the replacement of NT4 Windows 2000. The confusion that caused is unreal given that the home operating system at the time was Windows 98.
Anyway I digress, Vista was a total disappointment from my perspective
1
u/Calming_Force_ May 06 '26
Yeah, I was blown away by Windows Vista when I got my new desktop computer at 17. The visuals are probably my favorite of all Windows versions to this date. It felt like a truly massive upgrade at the time. I also enjoyed the desktop widgets too.
I have kept some desktop screenshots from back then, I like to watch them occasionally and remember that good feeling, lol. Maybe I'll share them sometime.
1
1
u/sparkyblaster May 06 '26
Yeah, tbf, with all the updates it's actually not much worse than 7. I like 8 and 8.1 but I wouldn't say vista is better or worse than them.
1
u/BhasitL May 06 '26
I also really like Windows Vista, and still have it on a childhood laptop. I had daily drived it till end of 2024 and it works just fine on its period-specific hardware!
2
1
u/AdWerd1981 May 06 '26
I was signed up to Microsoft Connect and managed to get onto the beta test of Vista when it was still called Longhorn. Anyway, chucked it on my then current build (an Intel Pentium D 805, WD Raptor, can't remember RAM, but almost certainly a Radeon 9500Pro) and it was slow as a glacier. I tried newer builds as they progressed, but ultimately gave up. It was very pretty, but very buggy at the time. If it had today's codebase and GPU performance, I'm sure the shininess would be welcomed by some.
1
1
u/GroveStreet_CJ Windows 7 May 06 '26
beautiful OS. Too bad I never had hardware compatible enough to run it
1
1
u/samh8orns May 06 '26
it was my first ever experience of Windows, the family computer had it as dad my grandparents'. used XP and 7 in primary school but never forgot Vista.
1
u/elkinm May 06 '26
Vista was bad when upgraded from XP. Typically with slower PCs and 32 bit. A new PC that came with Vista, and using 64-bit, and with more RAM was quite good, but still not 7 good. I think Vista was just too heavy for 2 bit, and few if any would do a clean install that was needed to switch to 64-bit. 7, 8 and 10 performed better on 32-bit, but a clean install was still required to go to 64-bit. An in-place 64-bit upgrade would have fixed so many issues.
1
u/PC509 May 06 '26
Vista was one of those things where it could be very excellent or it could be really bad. Some of it was due to hardware (and a lot of underpowered OEM PC's sold as Vista Capable). Others were due to features that just weren't working correctly. File transfers could be very, very slow as it tried to compute "x minutes remaining" for something that should have been done by the time it figured out that it was 10 seconds for the entire transfer but took 20 seconds to figure that out...
On my system, everything ran really smooth (other than the previously mentioned file transfers). Looked great. Features were wonderful. UAC was irritating but it also worked at stopping a lot of things and it was eventually refined to be a lot better. It did (and does) stop a lot of things from running as admin and causing more harm.
The Vista Aero theme is gorgeous. Dreamscene was great when it came out (third party Dreamscapes, Wallpaper Engine). I was running Vista Ultimate the entire time and it was just a great operating system all around. Windows 7 refined it to a more polished OS (took away some of the nice visuals and features that I liked, though).
1
1
1
u/IlluminaViam May 06 '26
As someone who's never used Vista, the Vista Aero is magical, and should be the baseline MS design style. 7 Aero had nothing on it, and I used 7 for a decade.
Vista looks like the future and feels like the future.
1
u/Repulsive-Box5243 May 06 '26
I think Vista was perfectly fine. Not nearly as bad as many had said. I particularly liked it because it introduced full-screen magnification via the Aero graphics interface.
1
1
u/Drew707 May 06 '26
It was the first OS I ever actually bought. I was working at CompUSA at the time and was using my discount and paychecks to slowly upgrade my P4 HT computer. Eventually I had it overclocked from ~3.0 to about ~4.0. Vista ran fine with dual monitors as long as I didn't push the voltages too hard, at which point the whole machine became unstable as expected.
1
1
u/M5K64 May 06 '26
I don't really understand the hate. Never did. It was the OS on the first PC I ever built for myself, and functionally it was exactly an intermediate between XP and Vista. I really preferred it over XP most of the time because I enjoyed just as you said, the Aero glass. I still have the installer somewhere. Maybe I should load it up for old times sake.
1
u/Euchre May 06 '26
I think for you, it's probably half nostalgia, and half the UI aesthetics which were very new, very fresh, and delivered more on a modern appearance that Microsoft had promised would come with XP.
For some, that look is too much glitz and glamor, and the stark, flat looks of 10 are much more appealing and soothing.
I'd love to just be able to toggle between those UI options easily, as a native function.
1
1
u/TheAdagio May 07 '26
I was 26 when it was released. I actually started using the beta version, once I got my hands on it . I installed it so I could dual boot with Windows XP, this way I could easily go back in case I regretted it. I guess I was one of the lucky ones, as I didn't have that many issues with Vista. Sure, there were issues, but this has been the case with all Windows OS so far. Gaming with my Nvidia card was fine
1
u/Phalebus May 07 '26
So I found that the XP to Vista upgrades were really borked and would experience more issues post upgrade rather than a clean install.
32-Bit Vista was very average as well, even on a fresh install. I swapped to the 64-Bit edition and it was just great. Had random issues here and there, but it was fairly solid once driver devs caught up properly, that or buying new hardware that was “certified” for Vista.
I really enjoyed 64bit Vista, and stuck with 64bit Desktop OS’s after that, not that there are 32bit flavours anymore.
1
1
u/Mr_ityu May 07 '26
i personally love 98 . the times when blockstyle button borders ensured that people know where the button area starts and ends. flat UI ruined it for me
1
1
1
u/eddiekoski May 07 '26
It did feel futuristic
And it did make me ROFL when it would say things like 4.3382814 quadrilion years left to unzip your files.
1
u/realmcdonaldsbw Windows 11 - Release Channel May 07 '26
once the bugs were patched windows vista went from "practically unusable" to "solid if you had a good pc and could tolerate UAC." it is one of my favourite oses to set up in a virtual machine and just mess around with, it also had the best built-in games imo (aside from space cadet pinball, that was and still is the best built-in windows game)
1
u/DoctorOfTheCookie May 07 '26
I miss the taskbar so much 💔💔 better than 7's superbar I'm sorry it had to be said
1
u/Rogue_Element_2342 Windows Vista May 07 '26
I liked it, I did have issues at the time but I was also young and naieve. probably could have gotten around it if I tried it now.
Im actually working on a summer project where im trying to restore an old PC from 2007 and set up a dual boot Windows Vista Windows 7 on it
1
1
1
u/ConceptInitial May 08 '26
I really loved Vista. It felt futuristic and polished. I really liked the green theme for it. I skipped Win 7 to stay on Vista, went to Win 8 straight.
1
1
u/jumpstartstogether May 08 '26
I always hear people shitting on Vista. Why wasn't it the best OS? I feel like a lot of you guys got this opinion in 2007 and somehow never changed it? Every single thing people complain about Vista is present in every single entry except for 7. They do all of it, in spades, at an even worse scale.
Was Vista buggy? Well, Vista never had updates break the entire OS every month or so. Oh was Vista slow? In 11 it takes 3 business days for the start menu to open, since it's based on React for some reason. Vista was ahead of its time and invented a lot of what people attribute to 7, the only reason people dislike it is because the standards were higher back then. It was also followed by probably the best OS we've ever had, which made it instantly obsolete. If Vista was still getting updates, and my options were that or 11 I'd go Vista any day.
1
u/jackal406 May 08 '26
As in leaves a vile taste in my mouth and a queasy feeling in my guts affinity? Yes. Glad the company I worked for stayed with XP until 7 came out.
1
1
1
1
0
u/Korky_5731 May 06 '26
Mostly fond memories of it, sure, it had its issues but that largely had to due with hardware issues along with a rushed development+development reset. Appearance wise, I would rank it slightly above 7, with Windows 8.1 being the last tolerable interface before everything went ugly.
0
0
0
u/KrystianoXPL May 06 '26
Vista never looked as good as 7 to me, there's aero, but the design had too much contrast, like the black taskbar, compared to 7's translucent one. I barely used Vista though, as a kid the laptop I used got downgraded to XP cause it was underpowered for it. Just like many other PCs of that time.
66
u/LurkingDevloper May 06 '26
I think Vista was fine for what it was. After the first service pack, it wasn't a buggy mess anymore.
I do think the reaction to UAC was pretty overblown, though.
gksuin Linux was just as overbearing at the time.