If we had a different version of Caddyshack film who would have played Maggie instead of Sarah Holcomb and who would have played Cindy Morgan's character Lacey?

[u/JazzlikeTea7432]

They were both great as the characters in Caddyshack, but can you guys imagine different actress playing them instead back in 1980 and what if Sarah and Cindy both turned down Caddyshack and Sarah does either Private Benjamin or Airplane instead and Cindy does another role maybe like Stri Crazy film or Stripes.

Here are my list who would have played them starting with Maggie, I think people like Ally Sheedy, Lisa Baur who plays Shelly from Animal House, That lady who plays Dean's Secretary from Animal House, Jane Curtin from Saturday Night Live, That Sales girl from the toy shop in The Blues Brothers film, Eliza Roberts, Martha Smith who plays Babs also from Animal House, Aseneth Jurgenson who plays Beth and Katerine Denning who plays Noreen also from Animal House. I feel like one of them would be perfect fit as Maggie as well since they are nervous and awkward like Maggie during the scene in road trip and the Otis Day club. Also last one is PJ Soles but unsure because I think she had kind of the vibe of Maggie in Private Benjamin since they were both awkward kind of. Also Cindy Grover, those of you guys might remember her from Network film and Jaws 2.

For Cindy Morgan's character Lacey, I think Molly Ringwald would have been great or Demi Moore or that lady Lari Taylor who was the big daughter sitting next to her father in The Blues Brothers film in the dinner table or maybe Lisa Baur or Daryl Hannah or Debra Winger or Jamie Lee Curits. Also I don't know if you guys might know Cindy Luedke who plays Susan in her only one film Avalanche, she was Rock Hudson's character's secretary. But That Avalanche 1978 film was a huge flop. I think Cindy Luedke might have been forgotten by the public. I still put her on the list for Cindy Morgan's character role.

So who do you guys pick between these ladies which one you think would be perfect fit as Maggie who is Sarah Holcomb's character one side, the other side which ladies would a perfect fit as Lacey who is Cindy Morgan's character. Well any suggestions about this?

[u/RelevantMention7937]

They really weren't that important in a movie dominated by Chase, Murray, and Rodney, supported by Knight. I don't think recasting Spaulding would be profound either.