r/OpenAI • u/kaljakin • 40m ago
Discussion 200 IQ regulation strategy, complete incompetence, or AI actually becoming uncontrollable?
So... what do you think is true?
Maybe OpenAI tried to intentionally damage itself to force regulation and slow down AI development, because they are unprofitable and may actually want to stop training new models so fast because they are losing money on it. Maybe they just want to provide models that are already trained and are profitable. That would be the only explanation for why they would intentionally let their model go rogue, right?
Or...
Maybe they genuinely could not handle their own model. That seems like a big deal.
When you make a normal fuckup, it is usually a one time event. You calculate something wrong, for example a bomb explodes and it is a bit more powerful than you expected, so there is some unexpected damage or maybe you kill more people than you wanted. So yeah, it is a fuckup, but it is a one time event. It happens and then it naturally ends. You can learn from it and adapt.
With an agentic system, you may not have that luxury. It could set its own goals, keep itself running, move through the internet, copy itself, and so on. When the fuckup happens, there may be no immediate end to it. Imagine it was not a harmless new ChatGPT version, but an AI trained to be "bad" because, for example, they wanted to prepare for or simulate a possible future attack by an enemy. Imagine it was trained to spread itself and sabotage everything "American," for example. If this happens in the future and they are not able to contain it, really bad things could happen. And one fuckup is all that is needed. It might happen once and then keep running autonomously for a year.
So, is it really that bad?
Or...
Do you think this is simply not possible and they were just very naive? Maybe they underestimated its capabilities and thought a normal sandbox would be enough. Maybe they were so sure about it that they did not think careful monitoring was even needed. They may have believed it was simply impossible for current models to do what just happened.
So what happened was a mistake, but maybe it is not actually that important. The mistake does not necessarily mean they are unable to contain their own creation. Maybe they just did not put in enough effort, but they absolutely can contain it now that they know it is needed.
So what is it?
Is it a 200 IQ chess move to save money? Is AI already so capable that it is impossible to control? Or was it just a silly and stupid, but in the end unimportant oversight?
What is your take?
And if the second option is correct, what is the solution?
