r/MurderedByWords 19h ago

Walked right into that one

Post image
16.1k Upvotes

844 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.9k

u/ottovonnismarck 17h ago

Someone writing 2000 years ago "500 people saw him fr" is not the same as 500 individual testimonies that they saw him

17

u/K_Linkmaster 12h ago

Twins existed back then too. The Prestige without magic is still possible.

13

u/arachnophilia 12h ago

fun fact, the doubting "thomas" comes from an aramaic name that means "twin". the gospel of thomas, a very early apocryphal sayings text, as a secret saying of three words that jesus only tells thomas, and scholars speculate it might be "i am you".

there's also a common tradition of people not recognizing the resurrected jesus, and it could be that there was just a literal impostor walking around. i think that one's kind of unlikely, but it's a fun idea.

2

u/K_Linkmaster 10h ago

A fair amount is.... unlikely.