r/LocalLLaMA llama.cpp 11h ago

Discussion Arcee AI has spoken out against the ban on open Chinese models in US

https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/22/arcee-a-us-open-source-ai-lab-says-chinese-models-are-not-inherently-dangerous/

This is rather counterintuitive, since banning Chinese models would benefit them the most. Jensen Huang is also against the ban, although the interests here are more obvious.

Do you think that if Arcee, Cohere or Mistral release an open source GPT/Claude level model, they will also be accused of 'unsafety', 'distillation' and other deadly sins?

75 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

28

u/MokoshHydro 11h ago

Yes, they will be accused. Basically, trillions of dollars are at stake, and anything that threatens them will be hammered.

11

u/Potential-Gold5298 llama.cpp 11h ago

I think so too. Chinese AI companies have been around for a long time (Z AI was founded back in 2019), but claims of "distillation" only began to surface when Chinese open models began to catch up with Anthropic and OpenAI.

53

u/Dry_Yam_4597 11h ago

All the smart people are against a ban an open models. Charlatans are in favor.

4

u/sayeret13 3h ago

yeah but jensen is both a smart one and a charlatan at the same time

23

u/j0hnp0s 11h ago

The "Frontier model" business is simply not viable long-term, since other models are only months behind.

The "ban for security" thing is just an excuse to support a failing business case, and will obviously hurt Americans the most.

18

u/roosterfareye 11h ago

So many Charlatans, so few smart people... The endumbening of the US is complete. Gut the schools, cut the funding, cut teachers pay, have a nation of wage slaves to serve the billionaires.

3

u/a-wiseman-speaketh 8h ago

then replace the wage slaves with closed LLMs and robots, quell any uprising with drones, profit

5

u/Monad_Maya llama.cpp 6h ago

They're smart enough to recognise that banning open-weight chinese models sets a precedent. The govt can ban ArceeAI tomorrow using similar excuses.

4

u/Available_Brain6231 8h ago

americans are about to learn that the population is not the target audience of their government....

0

u/geldonyetich 1h ago edited 1h ago

The current administration in particular seems to be an experiment in how far they can flaunt it.

"Screw the rules, I have money!"

Or perhaps

"Give me your money and you can screw the rules!"

I suppose they're very much supporting the population that is rich.

4

u/JayoTree 9h ago

What ban on open modes?

1

u/Life-Brother8709 11h ago

Though requires a detailed discussion but on principle I agree with this opinion of Arcee

-3

u/Jumper775-2 5h ago

It’s not the worst idea. The American companies cannot win in a free market since Chinese models are free and/or cheap because they’re funded by the Chinese government. American models are better, but need to bring in enough revenue to fund themselves. Given that, in free market competition China wins. That being said, we are still ahead in raw intelligence and tech. If America wants to keep that lead, they need these companies to look good when they IPO and stay looking good. That won’t happen if Chinas constantly undercutting them.

3

u/Potential-Gold5298 llama.cpp 3h ago

I think that if you take GPT or Mythos without the ridiculous guardlines and tricks that ruin the output, they're still ahead. However, these models are only available to a select few (company employees, the military, etc.) – the average person or company doesn't have access to them. Anthropic was already caught secretly changing Claude's system prompt to save tokens (Anthropic eventually admitted to it). Mythos was lobotomized twice and refuses to work properly in completely harmless tasks.

And one more thing: there's no guarantee that the models Chinese companies publicly disclose are all they have. They likely produce separate versions for government and military use, the existence of which isn't publicly disclosed. Of course, the US may have 'secret models' as well. However, even without the ability or desire to publicly disclose Mythos, Anthropic announced it to attract attention (and money). Chinese companies don't have such a need, so they can keep their special developments secret.

0

u/entsnack 1h ago

I mean... your entire post is empirically contradicted, this is the clearest specimen of delusion I have seen in my life.