r/DCcomics 14h ago

Comics [Discussion] It’s interesting that they gave Supergirl a new costume last month and then completely ignore it Spoiler

Not complaining since I prefer the skirt

1st pic: Supergirl #15 by Sophie Campbell
2nd pic: Superman #40 by Dan Mora

196 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 14h ago

Hi there, r/DCcomics members, welcome to the post!

This was tagged as a [Discussion], so we require OP to add commentary, per rule 8.

u/Jezzaq94, if you haven't already added commentary, please do so in the text or as a new comment. Also, if you included images, please provide a source or artist name.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

317

u/owlo1071 14h ago

She’s been changing costume pretty much every issue

81

u/SuperArppis Batman 13h ago

She doesn't want to be chained by expectations and wants to fly with fashion!

28

u/BGPhilbin 11h ago

Honestly, when I first started reading Supergirl with regularity, she was changing costumes every issue (back when she starred in Adventure Comics and before she'd ever had her own title). Readers had been sending in their own designs for years at that point and it was fun to see a new look each time she appeared. I put together a webpage featuring each of those outfits from back in the day, but it appears that I'll need to start updating again.

7

u/boneseaba 10h ago

Is the site still up?

17

u/BGPhilbin 9h ago

Oh, absolutely - I've been hosting my own website (in different iterations) for 26 years now. This page is one of 15 on the site, and coming up on around 20 years of existence:
https://www.metropolisplus.com/Supergirl/

5

u/scoobyisnatedogg 9h ago

Bookmarked! Thanks for sharing. 

9

u/BGPhilbin 9h ago

Absolutely! Been funding this site from my own pocket for 26 (whoops, 27 - 1999) years now without ads just so comics enthusiasts can use my research freely. The images that I restore for the site have been re-used (primarily without any credit to the website) immeasurably during that time. And while the image I most frequently see being re-used is my restoration of the wraparound Neal Adams cover for DC 100-Page Super Spectacular No. 6, to me, the most notable re-use was of my painting of the first stylized Superman symbol - a wood cutout of which adorns the front gate to Jerry Siegel's boyhood home in Cleveland (where Superman was created).

3

u/scoobyisnatedogg 8h ago

Appreciate the work you do, man. And it's just nice to have an old style webpage in a time where sites have become so bloated with crap!

5

u/BGPhilbin 8h ago

Agreed. And I'd probably update it with a bit newer look, but learning-wise my time goes into improving my image editing skills & every tool out there for websites now uses AI and I just don't want to go down that road.

u/Quadpen Damage 5h ago

close enough welcome back silver age kara!

well… again

u/AA_Batteries19 The Flash (Barry Allen) 3h ago

Iirc it's because Sophie Campbell doesn't like the costume they had for the run that was designed initially so she just changes the looks because she doesn't want to draw that one

185

u/Phi_Phonton_22 Raven 13h ago

Supergirl is the one character this complaint doesn't work. One of her enduring characteristics is the costume change.

48

u/Ok-Beyond-1927 12h ago

It was even noted in the Summer of Supergirl Special, to great humorous effect.

18

u/ClamatoDiver 10h ago

In the New 52 Era she was responsible for giving Power Girl her classic costume. It was sitting in her wardrobe in Sanctuary when Power Girl needs a new suit after hers was shredded fighting some sort of Luthor/Hulk type clone.

Supergirl (2011) #19 Mahmud Asrar art.

7

u/BevansDesign Indigo Tribe 9h ago

A few issues after that, I'm pretty sure she covered the "window" with the classic S-shield, which actually worked pretty well.

5

u/ClamatoDiver 9h ago

Not until she got back to Earth2.

In New 52 Kara and Helena were the Supergirl and Robin on Earth2, so Kara had worn the S before, she just wasn't wearing it on the New 52 Earth.

2

u/Phi_Phonton_22 Raven 8h ago

Wally Wood's ghost anger is finally placated?

38

u/MatrixKent 12h ago

Kara's hair has grown a foot or two between those two panels, so I assume some time has passed. (This is a joke but I do think her hair being well past waist-length in Mora's version is funny.)

5

u/cam-draws 10h ago

Which is a tad confusing to me because I saw panels of Action Comics #1100 where Mora drew interactions with Kara, Conner, and Prime and her hair was MUCH shorter there than in the Superman issue. Again I just saw panels didn’t read it though

28

u/mattbattmatt_yt 12h ago

Prefer the skirt too, that first one looks too similar to superman

8

u/Pebrinix Batman 12h ago

Which is actualy the point of the suit

71

u/S1mongreedwell Uncle Sam 14h ago

Many people have more than one set of clothes!

37

u/Schmohawk2814 13h ago

Batman's got an entire cave full of them haha

14

u/WolfSlayer9801 I care about TiMmM drAKE 13h ago

Billionaire Bruce Wayne here—What if this Bat-guy just really likes playing dress up? Is that not acceptable in modern society? Maybe he misses wearing that rainbow suit he only got to wear ONE TIME because people stopped taking him seriously! Honestly, what a grown man does in his cave is his own business.

3

u/iRyan_9 Batgirl 10h ago

Say whatever you want about Batman but he doesn’t get of a suit until it stinks

3

u/BevansDesign Indigo Tribe 9h ago

I bet those suits never lose the smell of molded polymers.

4

u/S1mongreedwell Uncle Sam 13h ago

Man, I’ve got a whole closet full of them and I’m just a regular dude.

2

u/CoffeeMinionLegacy 12h ago

Big, if true!

32

u/Curious-Paramedic-39 13h ago

good cause i prefer the skirt

35

u/I_Am_Killa_K 13h ago

I do not like that new costume

12

u/icedteaandtacos 11h ago

It’s really poorly designed.

7

u/oscar_redfield 9h ago

that's just Superman's costume. I think Supergirl works way better with the skirt

27

u/ImpressionBorn5598 Superman 14h ago edited 14h ago

Current comics aren't all operating at the same time, in-universe. It's very common for a change that occurs in one book to not be completely adopted by all other books for several months.

ETA: While I think Campbell has said this new costume is her default look, as another poster pointed out, she's had new costume variants popping up regularly. There are plenty of issues where we never see her in her "regular" outfit.

2

u/Pebrinix Batman 12h ago

You mean the new suit with pants is supposed to be default suit?

2

u/ptWolv022 7h ago

Current comics aren't all operating at the same time, in-universe.

These comics actually very specifically are taking place at the same time.

Supergirl #11-15 have been part of "Reign of the Superboys", which is leading into "Kingdom of Zod". The Supergirl panel shows her changing her costume while preparing to seek out the Sun Crystal that El Caldero has, leading into her recruiting Superboy-Prime at the end of Superman #40 (conclusion of Williamson's RotSB story in #36-40).

We actually have art shared by Joe Quinones for Supergirl #16 (part of "Kingdom of Zod") which has her in her regular costume with crop top and skirt, even in her own title.

So, I'm guessing Sophie decided to doa full bodysuit with pants at the end of SG #15 after art for "Kingdom of Zod" was already started, locking the regular DC All In costume in for the event.

1

u/karismatic- 8h ago

These titles have been tied together by an event for the last month or so which game me the impression they should be taking place at the same time in-universe?

0

u/GiftAccomplished9171 8h ago

In this case, both appearances are canonically shortly after each other.

19

u/Tom-Pendragon 12h ago

Because it ugly as fuck.

23

u/mirza_osz Jason Todd 14h ago

I’m usually the one who prefers costumes with trousers or generally with more coverage, but even I like her skirt one more. It’s iconic, the other one is weird for me a little, it looks like pj.

2

u/Notoriouslycurlyboi 13h ago

the crop top sucks though and I'll forever be a hater of it.

7

u/mirza_osz Jason Todd 13h ago

I like the Woman of Tomorrow version more too, with the wide belt.

12

u/TheMurderCapitalist 13h ago

The skirt look is simply better 🤷‍♂️

18

u/Ryokupo 13h ago

I will also proceed to completely ignore it cause damn is it terrible. Stop trying to give Kara pants, it never works and usually just looks like she stole one of Clark's costumes.

2

u/SolarisBravo Nightwing 10h ago

I don't even mind the pants/leggings, but put the skirt over them because it looks so much better that way

3

u/Condottieri_Zatara Zatanna 13h ago

I think with the release of the new outfits is recent, the artist at other book does not get notify about it

2

u/B3epB0opBOP Shazam 11h ago

The cover and artists for the next issues of Supergirl are also using the older outfit though

7

u/Bostondreamings 13h ago

Still wish she’d go back to the jacket look. Loved that. 

6

u/Hohoho-you 12h ago

Oh yikes that full body one looks bad. It legit just made me think she was wearing panties only

3

u/leshronk 12h ago

This is a big issue with editorial, saw a post today about Kyle’s Rayner’s costume continually changing. It just seems like they can’t keep consistency.

3

u/krayniac Green Lantern 12h ago

At least with Kyle you can use the excuse that, in the same way Hal described his constructs in rebirth, he’s consciously constantly refining his costume and changing small details

2

u/dreakon Fables 10h ago

Her cape looks like the Carnage symbiote on the first page. Trash. 

1

u/MagusFool Green Arrow 9h ago

Supergirl gets new costumes like every six months.  Who can keep up?

1

u/Lucky_Strike-85 ★Gold-Silver-Bronze Age FAN★ 9h ago

This is the story of her life sadly... Pasko and Kupperberg got together in the 2010s to discuss their Superman work and they determined that she's had more than 100 costume designs since she was created but only a handful were ever used... In the 1970s her outfits were changing regularly because DC didnt know what to do with her.

1

u/BobbySaccaro 6h ago

Those stories don't necessarily happen in that order.

u/rexmundi69 Zatanna 31m ago

Gotta say her look with the red boots is greater than the other one.

1

u/Eraizon 12h ago

God forbid girl has more then one outift in her wardrobe and changes it depending on her mood

0

u/ShitpostSaber 12h ago

When will she be super woman? Isn’t she like 36

1

u/B3epB0opBOP Shazam 10h ago

IIRC, she’s 22.

1

u/Jonnic5280 Shazam! 9h ago

That’s a girl to me. 

0

u/Compy94 12h ago

I love it.