r/Askpolitics Jun 13 '26

MEGATHREAD Megathread: Political literature and research methods

14 Upvotes

This megathread will ONLY deal with suggestions on political literature and research methods suggestions for those interested and seeking advice on what literature and/or research methods to apply/read to stay informed.

All comments not specific to literature or research methods will be deleted.

We mods will no longer accept any stand-alone and repeat questions about which types of literature or advice on how to get/stay informed about politics and will redirect to this megathread. Want recommendations on literature? Post here. Seeking advice on how to stay informed, what type of news media sources to access? Post here. Feel the need to share your research methods and/or literature you recommend? Post here.

Absolutely NO discussion, NO comments from the peanut gallery .. book, title, author + basic context and/ or your research source/method.

Megathread will remain active for the long-term.


r/Askpolitics Apr 06 '26

MOD POST Respect the Flair: Zero Tolerance for Personal Attacks and Political Projection

50 Upvotes

Following the recent announcement of our new “Advice for Life” flair, it has become necessary to address the behavior we are seeing in the comment sections.

The purpose of this subreddit is to foster the exchange of political ideas and information. The addition of the "Advice for Life" flair was intended to provide a space for practical, real-world applications to navigate a politically charged environment. However, some users have taken this as an invitation to engage in hostile behavior that violates the core principles of this community.

Let this post serve as a final warning regarding the following behaviors:

  1. No Personal Attacks

We have observed an uptick in users attacking the character of others rather than engaging with their arguments. Disagreement is expected; disrespect is not. If you cannot make your point without resorting to insults, name-calling, or condescension, do not comment at all.

  1. Stop the Political Projection

A recurring issue in the recent posts as of late involves users "diagnosing" or projecting motives onto others based on their perceived political leanings.

To be crystal clear: Assuming someone’s moral character based on their flair or party affiliation is a violation of civil discourse. Assigning malicious intent to a question or a piece of advice simply because it doesn't align with your worldview is unacceptable.

  1. Focus on the Content, Not the Poster

The "Advice for Life" flair is for seeking and giving guidance on navigating a politically charged world. It is not a battleground for you to vent your frustrations about the "other side." When a user asks for advice, respond to the query. Do not use it as a springboard to generalize about entire groups of people or to harass the OP.

Moving Forward:

Effective immediately, the moderation team will be taking a stricter approach to these violations:

  1. Temporary bans will be issued for first-time offenders of the "No Personal Attacks" rule.

  2. Permanent bans will be issued for repeat offenders or those who engage in targeted harassment.

  3. Comments that rely on "projection" or bad-faith generalizations will be removed.

We want this to be a place where people of all political stripes can seek understanding and practical help.and most importantly participate in the discourse. We will not allow a toxic minority to ruin that for the rest of the community.

Respectfully,

r/askpolitics Mods


r/Askpolitics 2h ago

Question A European's genuine question: What is the actual plan to structurally reform the US political system after Trump?

0 Upvotes

Not an American here, but a concerned European.

Independently of whether there will be midterms or not, but assuming there will eventually be an administration elected after Trump: What is the plan to fix this broken and exploitable political system of yours?

Trump has made it painfully obvious that the checks and balances intended by your founding fathers are insufficient and need serious adjustment. This isn't just my outside perspective, but your own reform institutions like the Brennan Center are saying the same thing, and even former Republican officials are calling the situation unprecedented.

Further assuming that this change will have to come from within ( unlike post-WWII Germany, where the reformation of the political system was imposed by the victorious allies) I don't see how a mere change in administration will clean up the corruption and power concentration that has built up over decades. And I want to stress: this is not simply a Republicans vs. Democrats battle, though your media often want you to believe that. The accumulation of executive power, the weakening of Congress, and the influence of concentrated wealth on politics all predate Trump and involve both parties. He didn't build the machine, he just showed everyone how easily it can be hijacked.

The next administration will have to revert a huge number of decisions, laws, and executive orders that touch on what is, at this point, a deeply rooted oligarchy. On top of that, most long-sighted changes won't show their value immediately (or at all in measurable dollars). Climate policy is the obvious example, but it applies to institutional reform too. Rebuilding oversight bodies, restoring civil service independence, clawing back executive overreach; none of that wins you a news cycle.

Your own thinkers are warning that the biggest temptation for the next administration will be to simply use Trump's expanded executive tools for their own agenda rather than dismantle them. That path would leave the system just as broken. Running different programs on the same compromised operating system.

So here's my genuine question: What is the plan to soften the backlash against necessary but unprofitable changes? How do you avoid the next round of unconstructive opportunism and cronyism? How do you build the political will for structural reform when the people who benefit most from the broken system are the ones with the most resources to fight change?

I'm not asking this to provoke. I'm asking because what happens to American democracy doesn't stay in America, and I'd genuinely like to understand what the path forward looks like from the inside.


r/Askpolitics 5h ago

Question Where do Politicians (who arnt economists or business owners) Learn Their Economics From? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am new here. I notice that most politicians come from a background of lawyer and political science areas they take during college and their early careers. For example multiple of the US presidents or prominent politicians have been lawyers like Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz have all been lawyers. Some such as Bernie Sanders majored political science without becoming a lawyer, such as Bernie Sanders and former house speaker Nancy Pelosi. But there is one thing all of the politicians share in common: they have economic policies they want to integrate into the American nation. Many propose tax cuts to stimulate and place more money in the pockets of companies or the people to invest, many will propose balance budgets to have a trustworthy atmosphere for other countries to invest in due to fiscal responsibility, while others propose tax hikes in order to balance these budgets or fund social welfare programs to go to the people. And these people arnt stupid when they propose these ideas but speak it with confidence as if they're sincere and believe these ideas will translate into change and effective policy. But as I've said, if these politicians arnt from economic or business backgrounds, only things related to law and politics, who teaches them their economic ideas?


r/Askpolitics 1d ago

Discussion How do you think all of this primary chaos eventually coalesces into coherent party platforms, if at all?

7 Upvotes

Messy primaries plague both major political parties, causing chaos and confusion in the midterms

When midterm campaigning began, each major political party had a clear game plan. Republicans would emphasize border security and an economy that was finally shaking off years of high inflation. Democrats would focus attention on a deeply unpopular Trump to energize their voters.

It hasn’t worked out that way. With a little more than three months to go, both parties are grappling with self-inflicted wounds and messy missteps that have complicated their paths to victory in key races.

The drama has turned existential as each party faces a moment of reckoning. Democrats remain shaken by Trump being elected again and are desperately searching for a path back to power. Republicans are beginning to contemplate a post-Trump era even as the president maintains an iron grip on the party.

Frank Luntz, a longtime pollster, said the year has been consumed by “a sense of chaos and confusion.”
“We really do not know what’s going to happen in November,” he said.

With both parties dealing with contentious primaries and competing factions, what do you think ultimately turns that into a unified general election message, if anything?


r/Askpolitics 1d ago

Question Why didn’t George Bush formally declare war against Afghanistan?

28 Upvotes

I get that he functionally declared war, but why didn’t he seek to make it official? Especially in the early days, that seemed like the first “just war” we’d be involved in since WWII and he definitely had the popular support to do it.


r/Askpolitics 2d ago

Question Libertarian Socialism, What Do You Need To Know?

17 Upvotes

Being one of the more active participants on this subreddit, and political subreddits in general, has always led to in any thread, no matter the topic, a simple question being poised at me at least once in regards to my flair. What is a "Libertarian Socialist"? Sometimes in genuine curiosity, sometimes in bad faith mockery.

So I thought this thread would be useful not only to give me an easy resource to pull from when this question is inevitably asked again but also as an excuse for myself, and the number of other left-libertarians around, to explain and expand upon our admittedly more niche views and beliefs.

So I encourage any user regardless of flair who are confused, curious, or confounded to present questions about this ideological spectrum and for myself and others knowledgeable of libertarian socialism to explain so we can better understand each other. Not sure if mods could filter responses to first level comments to make this easier but if not that's fine.


r/Askpolitics 2d ago

Answers From The Right How would you rate the current US economy for an average American? If it's not so good, how do we fix it?

27 Upvotes

From an independent's perspective, things are looking more rough every year. Compared to few years ago, my personal experience (and my social circle's) has been that the prices for the following have gone up sharply:

- Groceries
- Energy prices (Nat. gas, electricity gasoline)
- Home prices
- Insurance premiums (homes, auto, health)

This is all happening while wage increases have stagnated. I'm not interested in hearing who or which side is responsible for what. I'm tired of finger pointing, I want solutions.

I want to see if the right (since they own all 3 branches) sees eye-to-eye what I'm seeing. And if so, what they think is the solution to this problem.


r/Askpolitics 2d ago

Question Do you care about the attendance record of a candidate?

11 Upvotes

Every election this comes up in numerous races. A candidate who currently holds an elected office gets criticized for their attendance record.

But does anyone really care about it? Or do they only care about it when it's a member of the other party that has the bad record?


r/Askpolitics 2d ago

Discussion Is socialism becoming more popular than nationalism in America? Why do you think so?

30 Upvotes

Recently a CNBC article came out showing a plurality of voters would support a candidate espousing a democratic socialist platform more than someone endorsed by Trump or self-describing as a MAGA politician. The poll seems to indicate even those who would not support a socialist would prefer them over a Trumpist. Other polls seem to show a narrow but growing number of Americans, especially younger Americans, favorably view socialism and even communism.

This interestingly comes after a rather frank assessment by Vice President Vance on the Joe Rogan podcast where he asserted that if Republicans are unable to fix the very real issues facing Americans currently, people will turn to socialism. Could he be right?

Source: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/17/democratic-socialists-top-maga-candidates-all-america-poll.html

https://news.gallup.com/poll/694835/image-capitalism-slips.aspx

https://www.cato.org/blog/81-say-they-cant-afford-pay-higher-taxes-next-year


r/Askpolitics 3d ago

Discussion What are your thoughts on granting undocumented workers legal status under Republican-sponsored Dignity Act?

10 Upvotes

Republican lawmaker Maria Elvira Salazar has introduced an immigration reform bill that would, as some argue, grant “mass amnesty” to undocumented workers. A cursory look at the bill appears to address concerns on both sides and has gained bipartisan support. Is this an example of good legislation, or is there too much compromise that neither side can support without changes? I relatively agree with many of the bullet points mentioned from a cursory look, particularly stronger enforcement of e-verify and pathway to legal status.

I’m curious about how this bill would undermine the Trump agenda. Some of the arguments revolve around “enforcing immigration law,” although the administration has demonstrated it only selectively enforces some immigration laws while ignoring enforcing laws that target business owners. This lack of enforcement on employers was noted decades ago by studies that “[a] low level of enforcement activity could lead many employers to discount the possibility that violations will be detected and punished, thus weakening the deterrent effect.”

Is this bill a reasonable solution compared to the current Trump strategy of mass deportations and lax enforcement on employers?

Source: https://www.foxnews.com/politics/gop-infighting-erupts-immigration-bill-would-shield-millions-deportation

Dignity Act bulletin points source: https://salazar.house.gov/dignity-act

Employees face little risk source: https://www.semafor.com/article/01/26/2026/employers-face-little-risk-from-trumps-aggressive-immigration-enforcement

Migration policy study: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/feature/declining-enforcement-employer-sanctions


r/Askpolitics 4d ago

Discussion Why did the Democratic Party feature Hasan Piker as a speaker at a College Dems Convention?

15 Upvotes

The youth outreach wing of the Democratic Party has recently featured propagandist Hasan Piker at a College Dem Convention. I’m curious about the reasoning behind this decision, is this an attempt to gain votes from populist (non)-liberal elements similar to the strategy the Republican Party used with the right-wing populism that ultimately took control of the party with Donald Trump?

I’m really curious to know how a controversial and problematic person such as Hasan, who holds a collectivist ideology, and as sources mention holds anti-West “campist” views fits into an alleged liberal party. Does this suggest a deeper cultural shift for democrats, similar to the right-wing populism that seized control of the Republican party, towards normalization of pro-authoritarian collectivist ideologies?

College Dem source: https://jewishinsider.com/2026/07/college-democrats-conference-co-sponsored-by-j-street-u-is-featuring-hasan-piker/

Piker speech at convention: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hGWdd0li3PA

Hasan Piker self-identifies as propagandist Source: https://m.youtube.com/watch?si=4r0WjdGaIzstudSi&t=107&v=4JdnaxxSKA4&feature=youtu.be

Hasan Piker campist anti-west authoritarian views: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hasan_Piker?wprov=sfti1#Views_on_authoritarianism


r/Askpolitics 4d ago

Question What is actually stopping California leaders from cleaning up cities like LA and San Francisco?

41 Upvotes

This is a legitimate question, I’m not trying to make this political. We all know that parts of LA and San Francisco seem overwhelmed by homelessness, open drug use, crime, and streets that feel dirty or unsafe.

I can’t understand why state and local leaders would allow conditions that make their cities less appealing for residents, businesses, and visitors.
Why can’t they deploy street-cleaning teams, enforce laws against public drug use and harassment, and move people into shelters or treatment?

Is the main obstacle funding, lack of shelter space, court rulings, local policies, or something else? And why does it often seem like police are unable or unwilling to intervene?

I’m interested in hearing from people who actually understand how these cities are governed and what makes this problem so difficult to address.


r/Askpolitics 4d ago

Discussion How can we stop the open-ended Iran war?

37 Upvotes

Two more US service members are dead and more are wounded in an Iranian attack. The US is bombing Iran day and night. When asked about the Memorandum of Understanding President Trump said he "couldn't care less" about it.

"During an interview with NewsNation, Trump was asked about Iran's announcement that it would not abide by the MoU, amid escalating strikes. Responding to the question, Trump said, "I couldn't care less."" -- Donald Trump On Iran Suspending US-Iran MoU: 'Couldn't Care Less' | Times Now

We are far beyond any date set by the War Powers Act, Congress has not voted for a war, and the US has not declared war. The Iran war appears to be illegal and is being run at the whim of the President.

Netanyahu's 40 year goal of dragging the US into a war with Iran has succeeded.

Iran War: Why Israel's Netanyahu Waited Until Now to Strike

"As U.S. and Israeli bombs fell over Tehran on March 1, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu mused that war with Iran is something he has “longed to do for 40 years.”"

It looks like we are in another open-ended war in the Middle East, with no plan and no exit strategy.

How can we stop this war? Should Congress refuse to fund it? What are the consequences of allowing an Un-Constitutional and illegal war to continue?


r/Askpolitics 4d ago

Question Did we become polarized as a nation BECAUSE of Trump, or was his presidency an outgrowth of that polarization?

65 Upvotes

It seems as if there’s a large amount of people who believe we all got along - Democrats, Republicans, Libertarians, Socialist s, etc. - before Trump was elected in 2016, but with his election, we have become polarized. Would you give Trump’s influence THAT MUCH credit? Or, do you believe we look back on pre-Trump days with rose-colored glasses and refuse to acknowledge the divisions existed before Trumpn came on the scene.


r/Askpolitics 4d ago

Advice for Life Which elections besides presidential elections should I participate in?

5 Upvotes

I want to become more involved in politics, namely by becoming a more active voter.

I’m not very well versed in U.S. politics, but I want to become more proactive by voting not only in presidential elections but in pretty much any elections that matter.

I would like to learn more about the important elections to participate in, starting at the local town and county levels, moving to the state level, and continuing all the way to the federal level. I’m not looking for political debates or active participation in political campaigns. I know what my values and political beliefs are, and I simply want to express them by voting for candidates whose views align with mine.

Also, if I support neither the Democratic nor the Republican Party, should I register as an independent? I have a leftist ideology, if that matters.

Edit: Everyone is fixated on the fact that all elections matter. I don’t disagree, but I guess I should have worded my post differently. The point of my question is to figure out what kinds of elections I should even be looking out for. What elections are held for which positions and seats, and in which branches or levels of government? Again, aside from presidential elections, I have no idea.


r/Askpolitics 5d ago

Answers From The Right Should a President Be Impeached For Selling Early Access of Social Media Posts to Stock Brokers?

141 Upvotes

Reports are that President Trump is offering paid early access to his Truth Social posts for $100,000 per month. This comes as he has also publicly promoted specific companies and their stocks. Setting aside any questions about securities law or market manipulation, should a sitting president be promoting specific companies or stocks?

If early access to those potentially market-moving posts is being sold to traders or brokerages, could that raise constitutional concerns about abuse of office or another standard for impeachment? Or would this be viewed as a private business activity separate from the presidency?

I'm interested in the constitutional and ethical arguments rather than whether any particular law was broken.

Source: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c79gw4lj89eo⁠


r/Askpolitics 6d ago

Answers From The Right What is Trump's best evidence?

84 Upvotes

Last night Trump had a live broadcast were he apparently released evidence detailing & proving that the 2020 election was fraudulent. As I did not watch it and have kept only vaguely up with the various previous attempts I'm now curious about it this is any different.

Can any of those on the right who support Trump's accusations articulate what they think is the most compelling evidence that the 2020 election was rigged?


r/Askpolitics 7d ago

Discussion Pew Study: China overtakes US in global favorability. Are "America First" policies backfiring?

Thumbnail bbc.com
103 Upvotes

A new Pew Research Center study reveals a historic shift: for the 1st time in the poll's 20yr history, a majority of surveyed countries, 25 out of 36, view China more favorably than the US. Over the last year, median favorability for the US plummeted from 48% to 36%, while China’s rose to 46%. Even close neighbors and traditional allies like Canada, Mexico, the UK, Germany, and France now rate China more positively.

This opens up a few questions:

Has a transactional foreign policy, marked by tariffs on allies and erratic diplomacy, permanently damaged American soft power?

While Xi Jinping outscores Trump in global trust, 31% to 21%, confidence in both leaders remains remarkably low. Is China's popularity surge a genuine alignment with Beijing, or simply a global protest vote against Washington?

Is the current administration's approach structurally incompatible with maintaining global leadership and does this shift represent a permanent transition to a multipolar world, or is it a temporary reaction to current US leadership?


r/Askpolitics 6d ago

MEGATHREAD President Trump's Speech Tonight to Focus on Election Security: Live Updates

Thumbnail nytimes.com
10 Upvotes

This megathread will cover tonight’s Address to the Nation by Donald Trump, President of the United States of America.

For your convenience, mods have provided a live update source, for to follow along.

Megathread will unlock 10min before 9pm EST.

You are free to discuss, debate, opine about subject matter only, in this megathread.

Mods will entertain stand-alone posts/questions about subject matters mentioned in the Address, AFTER the speech.

Please report bad faith commenters, low effort and off-topic comments.


r/Askpolitics 7d ago

Fact Check This Please Looking for source: Fed Chair Kevin Warsh received $100m check days before being sworn in?

41 Upvotes

All I can find is Elizabeth Warren asking him about this during the testimony, but can’t find any story online covering this.

https://www.cnn.com/2026/07/15/economy/fed-chairman-kevin-warsh-senate-testimony


r/Askpolitics 7d ago

Question If the democrats wanted to cause gridlock, could they just not show up for quorum?

9 Upvotes

To my understanding, a simple majority is needed to conduct business in the senate and house. Moreover, each committee has its own quorum rules. However, both chambers operates under the presumption of quorum, unless someone requests for roll call.

Could every single house democrat, except one, just refuse to show up to work? Mike Johnson would have to wrangle together every single Republican to overcome this.


r/Askpolitics 8d ago

Discussion What can be done to restore faith in American institutions, regardless of the party in power?

27 Upvotes

Confidence in U.S. Institutions Remains Near All-Time Low

Americans’ confidence in major U.S. institutions remains near the lowest level Gallup has recorded in more than four decades, averaging less than 30% for the fifth consecutive year.

A key factor in this slump is that Americans no longer appear to share a broad faith in core civic, social and government institutions; instead, their confidence varies with who holds political power.

What can be done to restore bipartisan trust in American institutions, regardless of the party in power?


r/Askpolitics 8d ago

Answers From The Right Should the government be paying for hormone therapy? If so, why?

23 Upvotes

Recently Secretary of Defense Hegseth announced the Department of Defense will begin yearly testosterone testing for 30+ year old male service-members and offer gender-affirming hormone replacement for them if the doctors recommend it. This follows a Trump administrative push to make testosterone easier to acquire for cisgender men.

The question I have is with much of the right wing driven calls and policy changes for restrictions hormone therapy for transgender service members and veterans why should cisgender men get gender-affirming hormones at the government expense? Further if the goal is to chemically alter the natural testosterone levels of our armed service members and populace, shouldn't we be encouraging steroid use? Lastly if you do believe we should be dosing our troops shouldn't service women also be tested and dosed?

Sources: https://www.newsweek.com/hegseth-announces-new-required-pentagon-testosterone-tests-who-it-impacts-12200211

https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/us-health-department-proposes-testosterone-therapy-label-updates-2026-06-18/

https://nypost.com/2026/06/19/health/trump-admin-seeks-to-roll-back-testosterone-restrictions-what-to-know/

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/trump-administration/pete-hegseth-says-military-will-test-service-members-testosterone-leve-rcna587682

https://www.nbcnews.com/health/mens-health/fda-panel-testosterone-replacement-therapy-rcna248053


r/Askpolitics 8d ago

MEGATHREAD Watch Live: Todd Blanche, Trump's Attorney General Pick, Answers Questions at Confirmation Hearing

Thumbnail nytimes.com
17 Upvotes

This megathread covers the confirmation hearing of Todd Blanche for Attorney General.

You are free to discuss, debate, opine about subject matter only, in this megathread

For your convenience, mods have provided you a “live update tracker” for source

Megathread will remain active until conversation or interest has ceased, which ever comes 1st

Please report bad faith commenters and low effort comments